14 Best Ice Makers for Whirlpool Refrigerators – Stay Cool and Refreshed

For most shoppers, I rank the Whirlpool WPW10190965 as the best overall ice maker for Whirlpool refrigerators because it is a genuine Whirlpool assembly with several cross-reference part numbers. The Whirlpool WPW10300022 is another strong choice for compatible side-by-side models, while the Supco IM597 suits buyers seeking a replacement from a parts brand that serves multiple refrigerator makes. The main tradeoff is between a genuine-brand part and a compatible replacement, but neither label can confirm fit without checking your refrigerator’s exact model and existing part number. Connector style and assembly design matter just as much as the listing title. Read on for the full breakdown of all 14 options and the checks I recommend before ordering.

Before you orderOffer from Amazon

Get baking supplies delivered free with Prime

• Fast, free delivery on millions of items
• Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
• Member-only deals all year

Start your free Prime trial →Free trial for eligible customers · Cancel anytime

As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.Hide

Complete the kit

Non-slip Silicone Pastry Mat Extra Large Measurements 36’…

Add to your setup →

Katbite Silicone Baking Mat Set of 3 Grey

Add to your setup →

GTJ Silicone Baking Mat Roll, Reusable Baking Sheet Liner…

Add to your setup →

Key Takeaways

• Part-number matching matters more than broad brand compatibility: the roundup includes assemblies with overlapping Whirlpool, Kenmore, Amana, and Maytag claims, but those claims do not prove that a part fits every model.
• Genuine Whirlpool assemblies stand apart on brand identity: the WPW10190965, WPW10300022, W10873791, and W10884390 listings may appeal to buyers prioritizing a Whirlpool-branded replacement, provided the refrigerator model matches.
• Several listings share replacement numbers: the two W10873791 options and the WPW10300022/W10300022 options make exact suffixes and listing details especially important when comparing similar names.
• The W11088559 listing calls out a four-hole female connector: that detail can help narrow a match, but buyers still need to compare the connector and assembly with the refrigerator’s original part.
• Compatibility-focused kits and assemblies vary in scope: the FRIGESWIFT 4317943 is presented as a kit, while many other picks are assemblies; buyers should check what components are included rather than assuming every replacement contains the same pieces.

Our Top Ice Makers For Whirlpool Refrigerators Picks

W11546935 Compatible Ice Maker Assembly for Whirlpool, Kenmore, Amana, and Maytag		Best for a Matched 5-Pin Replacement	Model: W11546935	Compatible brands: Whirlpool, Kenmore, Amana, Maytag	Connector: 5-pin	VIEW ON AMAZON	See Our Full Breakdown
Mintu Refrigerator Ice Maker Replacement for Whirlpool Models (Part # 7WRS25FDBF02)		Best for Broad Model-Series Coverage	Brand: Mintu	Part number: 7WRS25FDBF02	Compatible models: Whirlpool WRS, MSD, ASI, and WSF series	VIEW ON AMAZON	See Our Full Breakdown
ClimaTek Ice Maker Replacement for Whirlpool WPW10190965, D7824706Q, 4317943, W10190965, and 1129313		Best for Replacing a Listed Legacy Part Number	Brand: ClimaTek	Model: D7824706Q	Replacement part numbers: WPW10190965, D7824706Q, 4317943, W10190965, 1129313	VIEW ON AMAZON	See Our Full Breakdown
Whirlpool WPW10190965 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly		Best Genuine OEM Replacement	Brand: Whirlpool	Part number: WPW10190965	Replaces: W10122506, W10122507, W10122510, W10190965, W10190966, W10190969, W10270037, W11381372, WPW10190965VP	VIEW ON AMAZON	See Our Full Breakdown
Ice Maker Assembly Replacement (W11700250/W11359448) – Fits Whirlpool, Kenmore, Amana & Maytag Refrigerators		Best for Low-Power Multi-Part-Number Coverage	Brand: Xizopucy	Model: ZBJ-BAI	Part numbers: W11700250, W11359448, W11546935, W11633658, AP7219248, AP7019172, PS17216974	VIEW ON AMAZON	See Our Full Breakdown
SURPOUF W11088559 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly, 4-Hole Female Connector		Best for Connector-Matched Replacements	Brand: SURPOUF	Model: W11088559	Compatible part number: W11284458	VIEW ON AMAZON	See Our Full Breakdown
Nurfosttek 2198597 Replacement Ice Maker, 185W, 115V		Best for Multi-Brand Compatibility	Brand: Nurfosttek	Model: 2198597	Part number: RIM597	VIEW ON AMAZON	See Our Full Breakdown
Whirlpool W10873791 Side-by-Side Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly		Best Genuine OEM Pick for Listed Side-by-Side Models	Manufacturer: Whirlpool	Part number: W10873791	Ice capacity: 10 cubes	VIEW ON AMAZON	See Our Full Breakdown
W10300022 Refrigerator Ice Maker Replacement for Whirlpool, Kenmore, and Amana		Best Kit for a Broad Brand Fit	Brand: Mintu	Model: W10300022 / WPW10300022	Unit count: 1	VIEW ON AMAZON	See Our Full Breakdown
Whirlpool WPW10300022 Genuine OEM SxS Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly Replacement Part – Replaces W10122556, W10300022, W10377190		Best Premium OEM Package	Brand: Whirlpool	Model number: WPW10300022	Part numbers replaced: W10122556, W10300022, W10377190	VIEW ON AMAZON	See Our Full Breakdown
W10873791 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly		Best for Part-Number Cross-Reference	Brand: Gartu	Model and part numbers: W10873791, W10760070, W10798411, W10847507, W10873791VP, W11130444, W11646278, NTPV303WA1, 4455326, AP6026347, EAP11738120, PS11738120, AWP42092, PD00030246, 045900892782	Unit count: 1	VIEW ON AMAZON	See Our Full Breakdown
FRIGESWIFT 4317943 Icemaker Kit for Whirlpool Refrigerators		Best for 4317943 Part-Number Replacements	Brand: FRIGESWIFT	Model and part number: 4317943	Replacement part numbers: RIM943, 4210317, 797991, 625601, W10122496, 833701, W10281545, W10190952	VIEW ON AMAZON	See Our Full Breakdown
Whirlpool W10884390 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly Replacement		Best Genuine OEM Replacement	Brand: Whirlpool	Model and part number: W10884390	Compatible appliance brands: Whirlpool, Kenmore, Maytag, JennAir	VIEW ON AMAZON	See Our Full Breakdown
Supco IM597 Replacement Refrigerator Icemaker for Whirlpool and Compatible Brands		Best for Side-by-Side Door-Bin Setups	Brand and model: Supco IM597	Compatible brands: Amana, Jenn Air, Kenmore, Magic Chef, Maytag, Roper, Whirlpool	Compatible part numbers: 2198597, 2198598, 626663, AP3182733, PS869316, W10190960, W10122502	VIEW ON AMAZON	See Our Full Breakdown

More Details on Our Top Picks

1. W11546935 Compatible Ice Maker Assembly for Whirlpool, Kenmore, Amana, and Maytag

   

   Best for a Matched 5-Pin Replacement

   View on Amazon

   I’d put this assembly near the top for Whirlpool owners replacing a failed unit with the same W11546935 part family. Its listed 5-pin connector and direct-install design can avoid adapting wires, but only if the existing refrigerator has the matching connector and a compatible original part number. Compared with the genuine Whirlpool WPW10190965, this aftermarket assembly is aimed at a different part family, so the two are not interchangeable simply because both fit some Whirlpool-branded refrigerators.

   The listed 1.5-pound capacity and low-power electrical specs offer useful fit and operating details, while the 12-month warranty adds some recourse. I would skip it if you cannot verify the connector or part number: installation also calls for disconnecting power and shutting off the water supply.

   Pros:

   • Designed for direct installation without rewiring or adapters when the connector matches
   • Lists compatibility across Whirlpool, Kenmore, Amana, and Maytag refrigerators
   • Covers several replacement part numbers in the W11546935 family
   • Includes a 12-month warranty and online technical support

   Cons:

   • A 5-pin connector and matching refrigerator part number are required
   • Installation requires disconnecting refrigerator power and shutting off the water supply
   • Aftermarket construction is not the same as a genuine Whirlpool OEM part

   Best for: Whirlpool, Kenmore, Amana, or Maytag owners who have confirmed their original assembly uses the W11546935 part family and a 5-pin connector.

   Not ideal for: Owners without a matching connector or verified part number, or anyone seeking a genuine Whirlpool OEM assembly.

   • Model:W11546935
   • Compatible brands:Whirlpool, Kenmore, Amana, Maytag
   • Connector:5-pin
   • Wattage:9.2 watts
   • Capacity:1.5 pounds
   • Dimensions:3 × 11.7 × 5.1 inches (D × W × H)
   • Warranty:12 months
   Our verdict

   “Choose this assembly if your refrigerator’s part number and 5-pin connector match; otherwise, the genuine Whirlpool WPW10190965 may be a better fit for a separately verified part family.”

   → See it on Amazon →

2. Mintu Refrigerator Ice Maker Replacement for Whirlpool Models (Part # 7WRS25FDBF02)

   

   Best for Broad Model-Series Coverage

   View on Amazon

   The Mintu is the most appealing pick here for owners who identify their refrigerator by a Whirlpool WRS, MSD, ASI, or WSF series rather than by a short replacement-part list. That model-series coverage gives it a different fit-check route from the W11546935-compatible assembly, which depends on confirming a 5-pin connector and matching part number. Its glass-reinforced, vacuum-insulated construction is presented as a durability feature, though the supplied data does not give electrical ratings or dimensions for a closer fit comparison.

   This is an aftermarket assembly, not a genuine Whirlpool part like the WPW10190965, so buyers should weigh broad model coverage against the uncertainty of aftermarket quality control. Installation may call for technical skill, and the product information warns that incorrect installation could affect warranty coverage. I’d verify the exact refrigerator model before ordering.

   Pros:

   • Lists compatibility across several Whirlpool refrigerator series
   • Glass-reinforced and vacuum-insulated construction
   • Offers an alternative to a genuine OEM assembly
   • Can suit buyers identifying fit by refrigerator series rather than a single replacement-part number

   Cons:

   • Aftermarket quality control may differ from a genuine Whirlpool part
   • Installation requires technical skill and may affect warranty coverage if done incorrectly
   • Electrical ratings and dimensions are not provided in the supplied product data

   Best for: Whirlpool owners with a WRS, MSD, ASI, or WSF-series refrigerator who can confirm their exact model is covered and are comfortable with aftermarket parts.

   Not ideal for: Buyers who want a genuine Whirlpool component, need detailed electrical or dimension specifications before ordering, or plan to install without suitable repair skills.

   • Brand:Mintu
   • Part number:7WRS25FDBF02
   • Compatible models:Whirlpool WRS, MSD, ASI, and WSF series
   • Material:Glass reinforced, vacuum insulated
   • Unit count:1
   • Product type:Aftermarket refrigerator ice maker assembly
   Our verdict

   “Pick the Mintu if your exact Whirlpool model is confirmed within its listed series and you prefer broad model coverage over an OEM-branded assembly.”

   → See it on Amazon →

3. ClimaTek Ice Maker Replacement for Whirlpool WPW10190965, D7824706Q, 4317943, W10190965, and 1129313

   

   Best for Replacing a Listed Legacy Part Number

   View on Amazon

   ClimaTek makes the most sense when the failed assembly matches one of its listed numbers, including WPW10190965, D7824706Q, 4317943, W10190965, or 1129313. Its 115-volt, 60-Hz specification gives more electrical detail than the Mintu replacement, whose supplied data does not list voltage or frequency. It also serves select Roper and Estate models alongside some Whirlpool refrigerators, which may help owners of those related brands.

   The main compromise is that the wiring harness is not included. That makes this a less complete replacement than the genuine Whirlpool WPW10190965 assembly, which includes the ice mold, maker body, and control device. Compatibility is limited to select models, so I’d match the refrigerator model and existing part number before buying rather than relying on brand alone.

   Pros:

   • Replaces several listed ice maker part numbers
   • Compatible with select Whirlpool, Roper, and Estate refrigerators
   • Lists 115-volt, 60-Hz electrical specifications
   • Automatically freezes and ejects ice until the storage bin is full

   Cons:

   • Wiring harness is not included
   • Compatibility is limited to select refrigerator models
   • May require sourcing or reusing additional parts for installation

   Best for: Owners of select Whirlpool, Roper, or Estate refrigerators whose existing ice maker matches one of ClimaTek’s listed replacement numbers and who can reuse or source a harness.

   Not ideal for: Buyers who need a harness included, cannot confirm an exact model match, or want a complete genuine Whirlpool assembly.

   • Brand:ClimaTek
   • Model:D7824706Q
   • Replacement part numbers:WPW10190965, D7824706Q, 4317943, W10190965, 1129313
   • Compatible brands:Whirlpool, Roper, Estate, and select other models
   • Voltage:115 volts
   • Frequency:60 Hz
   • Wiring harness:Not included
   • Included items:1 ice maker
   Our verdict

   “Choose ClimaTek when its listed part numbers match your existing assembly and you already have a suitable harness; otherwise, the genuine Whirlpool version is a more complete package.”

   → See it on Amazon →

4. Whirlpool WPW10190965 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly

   

   Best Genuine OEM Replacement

   View on Amazon

   For buyers who want a genuine Whirlpool OEM assembly, this is the clearest choice in the group. It includes the ice mold, maker body, and control device, and it replaces several listed part numbers. That makes it a more complete core assembly than the ClimaTek replacement, which does not include a wiring harness; however, this Whirlpool unit also omits the shut-off arm and front cover, so those pieces must be reused or sourced separately.

   Its main advantage is matching the appliance maker’s specifications, not universal fit. The listing covers only some Whirlpool, Kenmore, Amana, and Maytag models, so checking the refrigerator model remains necessary. The listed 120-volt and 180-watt ratings also differ from the low-power aftermarket assemblies in this roundup; buyers should follow the refrigerator’s specified part and electrical requirements rather than comparing wattage alone.

   Pros:

   • Genuine Whirlpool OEM component made to appliance specifications
   • Includes the ice mold, maker body, and control device
   • Replaces multiple listed Whirlpool-family part numbers
   • Compatible with some Whirlpool, Kenmore, Amana, and Maytag refrigerators

   Cons:

   • Fit is limited to specific refrigerator models
   • Shut-off arm and front cover are not included
   • The listed electrical ratings differ from the 115-volt, 9.2-watt assemblies in this roundup

   Best for: Whirlpool-family refrigerator owners who have confirmed WPW10190965 or a listed replacement number and prefer a genuine OEM assembly.

   Not ideal for: Owners who cannot verify model compatibility, need the shut-off arm and front cover included, or are matching a different low-power assembly family.

   • Brand:Whirlpool
   • Part number:WPW10190965
   • Replaces:W10122506, W10122507, W10122510, W10190965, W10190966, W10190969, W10270037, W11381372, WPW10190965VP
   • Compatible brands:Some Whirlpool, Kenmore, Amana, and Maytag models
   • Included components:Ice mold, ice maker body, control device
   • Not included:Ice shut-off arm, front cover
   • Dimensions:9.8 × 5.2 × 5.8 inches
   Our verdict

   “Choose this genuine Whirlpool assembly if your model calls for WPW10190965 or a listed equivalent and you can reuse or obtain the omitted arm and cover.”

   → See it on Amazon →

5. Ice Maker Assembly Replacement (W11700250/W11359448) – Fits Whirlpool, Kenmore, Amana & Maytag Refrigerators

   

   Best for Low-Power Multi-Part-Number Coverage

   View on Amazon

   This Xizopucy assembly stands out for listing several related replacement numbers, including W11700250, W11359448, W11546935, and W11633658, plus a specific 110 ml capacity per cycle. That makes it a useful candidate for owners whose refrigerator matches one of those part families and who want to address slow production, small cubes, or inconsistent filling. Compared with the W11546935-compatible assembly, it lists a similar 9.2-watt draw but adds the per-cycle capacity figure; neither listing makes model verification optional.

   The assembly is described as easy to install with basic tools, but its water-fill volume may need adjustment for suitable output. It is an aftermarket plastic unit rather than the genuine Whirlpool WPW10190965, so buyers prioritizing OEM construction should choose the Whirlpool option when their model calls for it. I’d confirm fit and be prepared to tune water fill after installation.

   Pros:

   • Lists compatibility with several Whirlpool-family replacement part numbers
   • Low listed power draw of 9.2 watts
   • Provides a 110 ml capacity-per-cycle specification
   • Described as installable with basic tools

   Cons:

   • Water-fill volume may need adjustment for suitable performance
   • Aftermarket plastic construction rather than genuine Whirlpool OEM
   • Exact refrigerator compatibility still depends on matching a listed part number

   Best for: Owners of Whirlpool, Kenmore, Amana, or Maytag refrigerators with a confirmed listed part number who want a low-power replacement and can adjust water fill if needed.

   Not ideal for: Buyers seeking a genuine OEM assembly, those unable to verify part-number compatibility, or anyone unwilling to troubleshoot water-fill volume.

   • Brand:Xizopucy
   • Model:ZBJ-BAI
   • Part numbers:W11700250, W11359448, W11546935, W11633658, AP7219248, AP7019172, PS17216974
   • Compatible brands:Whirlpool, Kenmore, Amana, Maytag
   • Voltage:115 volts
   • Wattage:9.2 watts
   • Capacity per cycle:110 ml
   • Dimensions:11.8 × 4.88 × 3.54 inches (D × W × H)
   • Material:Plastic
   Our verdict

   “Consider this assembly when your original part matches its listed numbers and you want low-power operation, but choose the genuine Whirlpool unit if OEM status matters more than broad aftermarket coverage.”

   → See it on Amazon →

6. SURPOUF W11088559 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly, 4-Hole Female Connector

   

   Best for Connector-Matched Replacements

   View on Amazon

   I’d shortlist this SURPOUF assembly when the existing Whirlpool ice maker has a 4-hole female connector and its model-specific fit checks out. Its food-grade ABS/AS liner and tray address the parts that contact ice, while automatic power-off protection and simple controls make it a practical replacement rather than a feature-heavy upgrade. Compared with the Whirlpool W10873791, this listing gives a more explicit connector detail but does not offer the same genuine-OEM status or stated one-year warranty; its listed warranty is six months. The 1-liter capacity and 12-volt specification are useful for matching parts, not proof of fit by themselves. I’d skip it if you cannot verify the connector and refrigerator model, since a mismatch can make an otherwise suitable assembly unusable.

   Pros:

   • Specifies a 4-hole female connector for comparison with the original assembly
   • Food-grade ABS/AS liner and ice tray
   • Automatic power-off protection
   • Simple ice-making and cleaning controls

   Cons:

   • Connector must match the refrigerator’s existing connection
   • Six-month warranty is shorter than the one-year coverage listed for the genuine Whirlpool assemblies
   • Compatibility should be verified by refrigerator model, not inferred from the part number alone

   Best for: Whirlpool refrigerator owners who have confirmed their original assembly uses a 4-hole female connector and want a replacement with food-contact materials and basic protection features.

   Not ideal for: Buyers who cannot identify their refrigerator’s connector or model, or who prefer a genuine Whirlpool part with a stated one-year warranty.

   • Brand:SURPOUF
   • Model:W11088559
   • Compatible part number:W11284458
   • Connector:4-hole female
   • Capacity:1 liter
   • Voltage:12 volts
   • Dimensions:11.81 × 5.12 × 3.95 inches
   • Material:ABS/AS
   • Warranty:6 months
   Our verdict

   “Choose this SURPOUF when your original Whirlpool assembly’s connector and model match; otherwise, favor a replacement with confirmed fit.”

   → See it on Amazon →

7. Nurfosttek 2198597 Replacement Ice Maker, 185W, 115V

   

   Best for Multi-Brand Compatibility

   View on Amazon

   The Nurfosttek 2198597 stands out for buyers checking a replacement across Whirlpool and several related refrigerator brands. It lists 185 watts, 115 volts, and eight cubes per cycle, which gives shoppers concrete details to compare against an existing unit. Its replacement-number list is broader than the SURPOUF W11088559 listing, but broad brand coverage does not guarantee a fit: the exact refrigerator model and part number still need to match. This assembly is also less complete than the Whirlpool WPW10300022, which includes wiring harnesses, an ice bin assembly, and mounting clips. Nurfosttek does not include a lifting arm, so you’ll need to reuse the original if your refrigerator requires one. I’d choose it for a verified cross-brand match, not as a guess based on brand name alone.

   Pros:

   • Lists compatibility across five refrigerator brands
   • Produces eight cubes per cycle
   • Provides a specific 185W, 115V, 60Hz electrical profile for fit checks
   • Food-grade materials

   Cons:

   • Lifting arm is not included and may need to be transferred from the old unit
   • Compatibility depends on the exact refrigerator model and replacement part number
   • Includes only the ice maker, unlike the Whirlpool WPW10300022 package with additional hardware

   Best for: Owners of compatible Whirlpool, Maytag, KitchenAid, Amana, or Roper refrigerators who can match the listed replacement numbers and reuse their original lifting arm.

   Not ideal for: Buyers who need a lifting arm included, want a genuine Whirlpool assembly, or cannot confirm compatibility by refrigerator model.

   • Brand:Nurfosttek
   • Model:2198597
   • Part number:RIM597
   • Power:185W
   • Voltage and frequency:115V, 60Hz
   • Ice per cycle:8 cubes
   • Dimensions:4.59 × 11.42 × 4.78 inches (D × W × H)
   • Compatible brands:Whirlpool, Maytag, KitchenAid, Amana, Roper
   • Included components:1 ice maker
   Our verdict

   “Pick the Nurfosttek when its part numbers match your refrigerator and you can reuse the original lifting arm.”

   → See it on Amazon →

8. Whirlpool W10873791 Side-by-Side Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly

   

   Best Genuine OEM Pick for Listed Side-by-Side Models

   View on Amazon

   For the Whirlpool side-by-side models named in its fit list, the W10873791 is my clearest genuine OEM choice. Its assembly makes and ejects 10 cubes, then refills until the storage bin is full, while the included housing means you are replacing more than a bare mechanism. Compared with the aftermarket Nurfosttek 2198597, this Whirlpool part has a named set of compatible models and a one-year warranty, but its fit range is narrower and installation calls for reusing the existing bail arm. The bail arm omission matters if the original is damaged or missing. Installation also involves refrigerator disassembly, so it is a less appealing project for a first-time repairer than a simple part swap. I’d choose it when exact model compatibility and OEM provenance matter more than broad brand coverage.

   Pros:

   • Genuine Whirlpool assembly for the listed compatible models
   • Makes and ejects 10 cubes before refilling until the bin is full
   • Includes the housing and complete ice maker assembly
   • One-year warranty

   Cons:

   • Fit is limited to select refrigerator models
   • Bail arm is not included and must be reused
   • Installation requires refrigerator disassembly and some repair experience

   Best for: Owners of the listed Whirlpool side-by-side models who want a genuine assembly with a defined model fit list and are comfortable reusing the bail arm.

   Not ideal for: Owners of unlisted refrigerator models, buyers without a usable bail arm, or novice repairers who want a straightforward installation.

   • Manufacturer:Whirlpool
   • Part number:W10873791
   • Ice capacity:10 cubes
   • Compatible models:WRS571CIHZ, WRS588FIHZ, WRS555SIHZ, KRSC703HPS, WRS588FIHV
   • Replaces part numbers:W10760070, W10798411, W10847507, W11130444, W11646278
   • Dimensions:7.44 × 14.44 × 7.38 inches
   • Item weight:1.43 pounds
   • Warranty:1 year
   • Included components:Genuine OEM side-by-side refrigerator ice maker assembly
   Our verdict

   “Choose the W10873791 if your side-by-side model is listed and you value a genuine Whirlpool assembly over broader aftermarket compatibility.”

   → See it on Amazon →

9. W10300022 Refrigerator Ice Maker Replacement for Whirlpool, Kenmore, and Amana

   

   Best Kit for a Broad Brand Fit

   View on Amazon

   This Mintu W10300022 earns its place for buyers who want several useful assembly pieces in one package: a head cover, bail arm, water trough, and instructions. That makes it a more complete kit than the Nurfosttek 2198597, which includes only the ice maker and leaves the lifting arm to be reused. Its compatibility list also reaches beyond Whirlpool to brands including Kenmore, Amana, Maytag, and Jenn-Air. The catch is that broad brand coverage still depends on the exact refrigerator model, and the power cord is not included. That omission can complicate a repair if the existing cord is damaged or unsuitable. Unlike the Whirlpool WPW10300022, this is not identified as genuine OEM and has no warranty details in the supplied specifications. I’d favor it when the listed assembly parts help your repair and the original cord is reusable.

   Pros:

   • Includes a head cover, bail arm, and water trough
   • Installation instructions are included
   • Lists compatibility across several refrigerator brands
   • Replaces the W10300022 and WPW10300022 part numbers

   Cons:

   • Power cord is not included and must be reused
   • Compatibility is limited to specific refrigerator models
   • No warranty information is provided in the supplied product data

   Best for: Repairers of a confirmed compatible Whirlpool-manufactured refrigerator who need a bail arm, water trough, and instructions included with the replacement assembly.

   Not ideal for: Buyers whose original power cord is damaged or unavailable, or those seeking a genuine Whirlpool part and documented warranty coverage.

   • Brand:Mintu
   • Model:W10300022 / WPW10300022
   • Unit count:1
   • Included components:Head cover, bail arm, water trough, installation instructions
   • Power cord:Not included; reuse the existing cord
   • Compatible brands:Whirlpool, Kenmore, Amana, Maytag, Jenn-Air, KitchenAid, Roper, Magic Chef
   Our verdict

   “Choose this Mintu kit when your refrigerator model matches and you want the bail arm and water trough included, with a usable original cord on hand.”

   → See it on Amazon →

10. Whirlpool WPW10300022 Genuine OEM SxS Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly Replacement Part – Replaces W10122556, W10300022, W10377190

    

    Best Premium OEM Package

    View on Amazon

    The WPW10300022 is the strongest pick here for buyers who want a genuine Whirlpool assembly with extra installation hardware. Its package includes three wiring harnesses, an ice bin assembly, and two mounting clips, giving it a more extensive parts bundle than the Whirlpool W10873791, which includes the housing but requires the old bail arm. This model also lists replacement numbers and fits multiple Whirlpool refrigerators with in-door ice and water dispensers. The tradeoff is that a wide fit claim still needs checking against the exact refrigerator model, and the bail arm is not included. Repair work also requires shutting off water and power, so convenience-minded owners may prefer professional help. The stated one-year limited warranty and included hardware make this a more supported route than the Mintu W10300022, but only if the model match is confirmed.

    Pros:

    • Genuine Whirlpool OEM assembly
    • Includes three wiring harnesses, an ice bin assembly, and two mounting clips
    • Replaces three listed part numbers
    • One-year limited warranty

    Cons:

    • Bail arm is not included and must be reused
    • Installation requires shutting off water and power
    • Compatibility still needs confirmation for the exact refrigerator model

    Best for: Whirlpool side-by-side owners with in-door ice and water dispensers who want a genuine assembly, included mounting hardware, and a one-year limited warranty.

    Not ideal for: Buyers whose refrigerator model is not confirmed compatible, or those without a reusable bail arm who want every component included.

    • Brand:Whirlpool
    • Model number:WPW10300022
    • Part numbers replaced:W10122556, W10300022, W10377190
    • Warranty:1-year limited warranty
    • Included components:Ice maker assembly, 3 wiring harnesses, ice bin assembly, 2 mounting clips
    • Ice production:Up to 8 cubes at a time
    • Compatible refrigerator type:Multiple Whirlpool models with in-door ice and water dispensers
    Our verdict

    “Choose this Whirlpool OEM package when your in-door dispenser model matches and you want the included bin and mounting hardware.”

    → See it on Amazon →

11. W10873791 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly

    

    Best for Part-Number Cross-Reference

    View on Amazon

    This Gartu assembly makes the most sense when your existing ice maker matches one of its many listed replacement numbers, including W10873791 and W10760070. That broad cross-reference list gives it a different advantage from the FRIGESWIFT 4317943 kit, which centers on a separate set of parts and Whirlpool models. The unit is described as factory tested and made from durable materials, and its one-year warranty adds a defined support period. Still, a long part-number list is not proof that the assembly fits every Whirlpool refrigerator: the product data limits compatibility to select models. I would verify the refrigerator’s exact model and existing part number before ordering. Buyers who want a genuine Whirlpool-branded replacement may prefer the W10884390 instead, while this option suits shoppers prioritizing cross-referenced part numbers.

    Pros:

    • Lists numerous replacement part numbers for cross-referencing
    • Described as factory tested and made from durable materials
    • Includes a one-year warranty

    Cons:

    • Fits only select refrigerator models, so part-number matching alone may not confirm fit
    • Brand is Gartu rather than Whirlpool OEM

    Best for: Whirlpool refrigerator owners whose existing ice maker carries one of the listed W10873791-series replacement numbers and who have confirmed model compatibility.

    Not ideal for: Buyers who cannot confirm their refrigerator model or part number, or who specifically want a genuine Whirlpool-branded assembly.

    • Brand:Gartu
    • Model and part numbers:W10873791, W10760070, W10798411, W10847507, W10873791VP, W11130444, W11646278, NTPV303WA1, 4455326, AP6026347, EAP11738120, PS11738120, AWP42092, PD00030246, 045900892782
    • Unit count:1
    • Warranty:1 year
    • Compatibility:Select refrigerator models; verify model before purchase
    • Testing:Tested before shipment
    Our verdict

    “Choose this Gartu assembly if your refrigerator model and existing part number match its compatibility list; otherwise, verify fit before choosing it over the Whirlpool W10884390.”

    → See it on Amazon →

12. FRIGESWIFT 4317943 Icemaker Kit for Whirlpool Refrigerators

    

    Best for 4317943 Part-Number Replacements

    View on Amazon

    The FRIGESWIFT kit is a focused replacement choice for buyers whose existing ice maker matches 4317943 or one of its listed equivalents, such as RIM943 and W10122496. Its 115-volt, 185-watt specifications and compact listed dimensions give repair shoppers concrete details to compare with the part they are removing. Unlike the Gartu W10873791 assembly, this kit’s replacement-number list is centered on the 4317943 family, so the two are not interchangeable just because both target Whirlpool refrigerators. The main tradeoff is fit: the manufacturer lists compatibility with select models, not every Whirlpool refrigerator. I would match both the refrigerator model and old part number before buying. The product data also lists a 1-liter capacity, but does not describe installation guidance or a warranty, making it less documented than the Whirlpool W10884390.

    Pros:

    • Replacement list covers several 4317943-family part numbers
    • Lists voltage and wattage for electrical comparison
    • Provides physical dimensions for fit checks

    Cons:

    • Compatibility is limited to select Whirlpool refrigerator models
    • Product data does not state a warranty or installation instructions
    • The listed 1-liter capacity may not be directly comparable to daily ice output

    Best for: Owners of select Whirlpool refrigerators replacing an ice maker marked 4317943, RIM943, W10122496, or another listed equivalent.

    Not ideal for: Shoppers whose refrigerator uses a different part-number family, or buyers who need a listing with stated installation support or warranty details.

    • Brand:FRIGESWIFT
    • Model and part number:4317943
    • Replacement part numbers:RIM943, 4210317, 797991, 625601, W10122496, 833701, W10281545, W10190952
    • Compatibility:Select Whirlpool refrigerator models
    • Capacity:1 liter
    • Voltage and wattage:115 volts; 185 watts
    • Dimensions:11.4 × 4.6 × 4.8 inches
    • Included components:4317943 icemaker kit
    Our verdict

    “Pick the FRIGESWIFT kit when your model and old part number match its 4317943 family, but choose a better-documented option if warranty details matter.”

    → See it on Amazon →

13. Whirlpool W10884390 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly Replacement

    

    Best Genuine OEM Replacement

    View on Amazon

    For buyers who want a genuine Whirlpool part, the W10884390 is the clearest choice in this group. Its assembly includes both the ice mold and control device, which makes it a complete replacement for those components rather than a listing centered mainly on cross-reference numbers, like the Gartu W10873791. The product data names compatibility with Whirlpool, Kenmore, Maytag, and JennAir appliances, but still calls for checking the exact refrigerator model. Installation involves disassembly and basic hand tools; the refrigerator must be unplugged and its water supply shut off first. That makes it less suitable for someone seeking a simple, tool-free fix than the Supco IM597, though the Supco has its own missing-parts tradeoffs. A one-year warranty and OEM status make this a strong pick for model-matched repairs, not a universal fit.

    Pros:

    • Genuine Whirlpool OEM part
    • Includes both the ice mold and control device
    • Listed for compatible Whirlpool, Kenmore, Maytag, and JennAir appliances
    • Includes a one-year warranty

    Cons:

    • Installation requires appliance disassembly and basic hand tools
    • Requires unplugging the refrigerator and shutting off its water supply
    • Not compatible with every refrigerator model

    Best for: Repair-minded owners of compatible Whirlpool, Kenmore, Maytag, or JennAir refrigerators who want a genuine OEM assembly with the mold and control device included.

    Not ideal for: Buyers seeking a quick tool-free replacement, or anyone who has not confirmed compatibility with the refrigerator’s exact model.

    • Brand:Whirlpool
    • Model and part number:W10884390
    • Compatible appliance brands:Whirlpool, Kenmore, Maytag, JennAir
    • Included assembly components:Ice mold and control device
    • Item weight:4 pounds
    • Unit count:1
    • Warranty:1 year
    • UPC:883049445717
    Our verdict

    “Choose the W10884390 for a model-verified repair where OEM status and a complete mold-and-control assembly matter more than easy installation.”

    → See it on Amazon →

14. Supco IM597 Replacement Refrigerator Icemaker for Whirlpool and Compatible Brands

    

    Best for Side-by-Side Door-Bin Setups

    View on Amazon

    The Supco IM597 is the most specifically described fit here for a side-by-side refrigerator with an ice bin in the freezer door. Its fuse-protected 10.5-inch, four-pin connector and included ice stripper are useful details for checking whether it matches the existing setup. That specificity separates it from the Whirlpool W10884390, which is presented as a broader OEM assembly for several appliance brands but does not list connector details. Supco’s compatibility list includes Whirlpool and several related brands, plus named refrigerator models and part numbers. The tradeoff is that the kit includes only the icemaker: no water valve or ice bucket comes with it. Buyers replacing more than the icemaker itself should plan for separate parts. Model and connector verification are still necessary; shared branding alone does not confirm fit.

    Pros:

    • Designed for compatible side-by-side refrigerators with a freezer-door ice bin
    • Includes a fuse-protected four-pin connector
    • Ice stripper helps direct cubes into the bin
    • Lists compatible brands, part numbers, and several refrigerator models

    Cons:

    • Does not include a water valve or ice bucket
    • Fit depends on matching the refrigerator model and connector
    • Listed compatibility does not cover every Whirlpool refrigerator

    Best for: Owners of compatible side-by-side refrigerators with a freezer-door ice bin who can match the existing four-pin connector and listed model or part number.

    Not ideal for: Buyers who need a water valve or ice bucket included, or owners of refrigerators without the specified door-bin setup.

    • Brand and model:Supco IM597
    • Compatible brands:Amana, Jenn Air, Kenmore, Magic Chef, Maytag, Roper, Whirlpool
    • Compatible part numbers:2198597, 2198598, 626663, AP3182733, PS869316, W10190960, W10122502
    • Compatible refrigerator models:Whirlpool ED22TQXEW01, ED5THAXMS00, EDSHAMXB002, GC5NHAXVQ01, GD5SHAXNB00, GS6NBEXRSOO, GS6SHEXNL00, WRS325FDAM02
    • Voltage:115 volts
    • Connector:Four-pin flat connector, 10.5 inches long
    • Item weight:2.8 pounds
    • Included components:Icemaker only
    Our verdict

    “Select the IM597 when your side-by-side model and four-pin door-bin connection match; choose another kit if you need a valve or bucket included.”

    → See it on Amazon →

How We Picked

I ranked these ice makers for Whirlpool refrigerators around the checks that affect a successful replacement: clarity of the stated part numbers, connection details, whether the listing identifies a Whirlpool-branded or compatible assembly, and how readily a buyer can compare the replacement with the original. I gave more weight to listings with recognizable Whirlpool part numbers or explicit cross-references, but treated compatibility claims as a starting point rather than proof of fit. A product that names a connector or model family can help a buyer investigate fit; it cannot replace checking the refrigerator’s model number.

The ranking favors options that make part identification more straightforward and separates genuine Whirlpool listings from third-party alternatives, kits, and broader compatibility claims. That does not mean a branded part automatically fits better, or that a compatible assembly is inherently inferior. A lower-ranked product may be the better choice when its exact part number matches the refrigerator. I also considered the risk of confusion among listings with similar replacement numbers, since choosing the wrong variant can outweigh any difference in brand or listing breadth.

Factors to Consider When Choosing Ice Makers For Whirlpool Refrigerators

Before choosing an ice maker, treat the refrigerator’s model label and the existing assembly as your reference points. The listings in this roundup use overlapping part numbers, brand names, and replacement claims, so a familiar product title alone is not enough to confirm a match. These checks can help you narrow the options and avoid ordering based on appearance or brand alone.

Match the Refrigerator Model, Not Just the Brand

Whirlpool, Kenmore, Amana, and Maytag models can share components, but a compatibility claim covering several brands is not a fit guarantee. Find the full refrigerator model number on the appliance label and use a parts lookup or the manufacturer’s documentation to identify the correct ice maker assembly. Compare the result with the listing’s supported part numbers, including any suffixes. A partial match may point to a related component rather than the right replacement. If the model lookup and listing disagree, pause and confirm with the seller or a parts professional before ordering.

Use the Old Part Number as a Cross-Check

When accessible, read the number printed on the original assembly and compare it with both the replacement number and listed superseded numbers. Listings such as WPW10190965 and WPW10300022 name multiple cross-references, which can be useful if your original part carries an older number. Do not assume two listings are interchangeable just because they share one number; check every replacement reference and the appliance model. Keep a photo of the label and connector for comparison. If the old assembly is missing or unreadable, the refrigerator model lookup becomes even more important.

Check the Connector and Mounting Style

Electrical connectors and mounting points can differ between assemblies that look similar in a product photo. The SURPOUF W11088559 listing specifies a four-hole female connector, a useful clue only when it matches the original part. Compare the connector shape, wire orientation, mounting tabs, and overall assembly layout before buying. Avoid relying on a seller image alone, since photos may show a representative item or a different production version. A mismatch can turn an otherwise compatible part into an installation problem.

Know Whether You Need an Assembly or a Kit

A replacement assembly and an icemaker kit may include different components, so check the item contents before treating them as equivalent. The FRIGESWIFT 4317943 is described as a kit, while many other listings identify an assembly. Buyers replacing a failed ice maker may need only the assembly, but a repair involving missing hardware or related pieces could call for a broader kit. Read the included-parts list and installation notes instead of inferring contents from the word “kit.” If the listing does not say what is included, ask before placing an order.

Choose Between Genuine Whirlpool and Compatible Parts

A Whirlpool-branded listing can make the part identity easier to trace, while a compatible replacement may offer another route when its number and specifications match your refrigerator. The brand name alone does not resolve fit, and a broad compatible-brand list does not show how closely the part matches the original. Compare exact part references, connector details, return terms, and any stated warranty. Paying more for a branded assembly makes the most sense when you value brand continuity and can verify the number. A compatible option is a sensible candidate when it has a confirmed match and clearly stated specifications.

Plan for Installation and Safe Handling

Replacing an ice maker involves electrical connections and work inside the freezer, so check the manufacturer’s instructions before starting. Disconnect power and follow the refrigerator’s service guidance; do not force a connector or mounting point that does not line up. Some buyers will find the job manageable with clear instructions, while others may prefer a qualified appliance technician. If the ice maker is not the source of the problem, replacing it may not restore ice production. Check for related water-supply or refrigerator issues before treating the assembly as the only possible cause.

Frequently Asked Questions

How can I tell which of these ice makers fits my Whirlpool refrigerator?

Start with the refrigerator’s complete model number, then look up the specified ice maker assembly in the manufacturer’s parts information or a trusted parts database. Compare that result with the listing’s exact part number and any stated replacement numbers. Check the connector and mounting arrangement against the existing assembly as an additional cross-check. A listing that says it fits Whirlpool refrigerators generally does not confirm compatibility with your particular model. If the references do not line up, verify with the seller or a parts specialist before ordering.

Are WPW10190965 and WPW10300022 interchangeable?

Do not assume these assemblies are interchangeable based only on their similar names or replacement claims. Each listing provides its own part-number references, and the correct choice depends on the refrigerator model and the original assembly number. Look up your appliance model and confirm that the specific replacement number is approved for it. Also compare connector and mounting details if the original part is available. If both listings appear to match, confirm the supersession information before choosing between them.

Should I choose a genuine Whirlpool ice maker or a compatible replacement?

Choose based on confirmed fit and the evidence each listing provides, not the brand label alone. A genuine Whirlpool assembly may appeal if you want a part identified by the appliance brand and its number matches your refrigerator. A compatible replacement can also be a reasonable choice when the exact part references, connector, and mounting style agree with the original. Compare warranty and return terms as well, since those affect your options if the part does not fit. Neither category is a safe choice without model-specific verification.

Does the four-hole connector on the SURPOUF W11088559 mean it will fit my refrigerator?

No. The connector description is a helpful identification detail, not a complete compatibility check. Your refrigerator also needs to match the assembly’s part number, wiring configuration, and mounting points. Compare the original connector and part label with the listing details, then verify the appliance model. If only the connector appears to match, keep checking before ordering. A connector that looks similar may still differ in wiring or assembly design.

When should I pick an icemaker kit instead of a replacement assembly?

Pick a kit when its included components match the scope of your repair, rather than assuming the word “kit” means it is a more complete or better replacement. An assembly may be enough when the failed component is the ice maker itself and the existing supporting parts are intact. Review the kit’s contents and installation notes to see whether it includes anything you actually need. Confirm that its part number is approved for your refrigerator model. If the listing does not clearly describe the contents, ask the seller before buying.

Conclusion

My best overall pick is the Whirlpool WPW10190965 for buyers whose model lookup confirms its part number; its Whirlpool identity and listed cross-references make it a clear starting point. For best value, compare compatible assemblies such as the W11546935 or W10300022 against the exact original part number and connector rather than choosing by brand coverage alone. The best premium route is a genuine Whirlpool assembly that matches your model, such as the WPW10300022 or W10873791; their branding does not make them universal fits. For beginners, I favor the listing with the clearest match to the existing assembly and straightforward parts information, then recommend confirming fit before attempting installation. For a specific connector clue, investigate the SURPOUF W11088559; for a kit-style option, check the FRIGESWIFT 4317943’s included components. In every case, let your refrigerator model and original part number make the final call.