The best Frigidaire ice maker for most countertop users is the Gallery EFIC255 Nugget Ice Maker, which pairs chewable ice with a stated 44-pound daily capacity. For a smaller, simpler setup, the EFIC117 portable bullet-ice models focus on compact convenience, while refrigerator owners may need a compatible replacement assembly kit instead of a standalone machine. The main tradeoffs are ice style, counter space, daily output, maintenance, and whether you need a new appliance or a repair part. I compare all 15 options by those needs so you can narrow the field. Continue reading for the full breakdown and guidance on choosing the right Frigidaire ice maker.
Get baking supplies delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Nugget ice and bullet ice serve different routines: the Gallery EFIC255 and other nugget models prioritize chewable ice, while EFIC117 and other bullet machines are geared toward straightforward countertop batches.
- Daily output figures do not tell the whole story: a 44-pound-per-day claim may suit frequent use, but buyers still need to think about storage, refilling, and how quickly ice is used.
- Several listings are refrigerator repair parts, not countertop machines: IM116000, 241798231, and compatible replacement assemblies require a model-fit check before purchase.
- The 44-pound nugget models differ more by controls and finish than by stated capacity: the touchscreen slate model adds a distinct interface, while Gallery and cream options share the headline output.
- EFIC117 variants emphasize choice of finish rather than a different stated daily output: compare the listing details and footprint before paying more for a color or surface treatment.
| Frigidaire EFIC128AMZBLK Compact Countertop Ice Maker, Black |  | Best for Quick, Everyday Bullet Ice | Model: EFIC128AMZBLK | Type: Countertop portable ice maker | Color: Black | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Frigidaire IM116000 Ice Maker Assembly Kit for Refrigerators |  | Best for Compatible Refrigerator Repairs | Model: IM116000 | Item type: Ice maker assembly | Color: White | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Frigidaire Gallery EFIC255 Countertop Nugget Ice Maker, 44 lb per Day, Navy |  | Best for High-Volume Nugget Ice | Model: EFIC255-NAVY | Ice type: Chewable nugget ice | Color: Navy | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Frigidaire 241798231 Ice Maker Assembly Kit for Refrigerators |  | Best for a Specified FFHS2322MS Repair | Model: 241798231 | Part type: Ice maker assembly | Compatible refrigerator model: Frigidaire FFHS2322MS | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Frigidaire Countertop Chewable Nugget Ice Maker |  | Best Compact Nugget-Ice Pick | Model: EFIC22BAMZ | Ice type: Chewable nugget ice | Ice production per day: Up to 33 lb | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Kitchen Basics 101 Ice Maker Replacement for Electrolux and Frigidaire Refrigerators |  | Best Replacement Part for Select Frigidaire Refrigerators | Cubes per cycle: 8 | Shut-off: Automatic arm | Dimensions: 4.5 × 4.75 × 11.3 inches | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Frigidaire Touchscreen Nugget Ice Maker, 33 lb Daily Capacity, Slate |  | Best for Touchscreen Controls and Countertop Nugget Ice | Model: EFIC2320BLK | Daily ice production: 33 lbs. | Water tank capacity: 1.8 L | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Frigidaire Gallery Countertop Nugget Ice Maker, 44 lbs per Day, Black |  | Best for High-Output Nugget Ice | Model: EFIC165 | Ice production per day: Up to 44 lbs. | Ice bin capacity: 3 lbs. | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Frigidaire EFIC117 Portable Countertop Ice Maker, Red Stainless Steel |  | Best Compact Bullet-Ice Pick | Model: EFIC117-SSRED-COM | Ice type: Bullet-shaped | Daily ice production: Up to 26 lbs. | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Frigidaire Nugget Ice Maker, 44 lb Daily Capacity, Cream |  | Best Compact-Footprint Nugget Ice Maker | Model: EFIC255-CREAM | Daily ice production: Up to 44 lbs. | Ice bin capacity: 3 lbs. | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Ice Maker Replacement for Select Frigidaire, Electrolux, and Kenmore Refrigerators |  | Best for Broad Part-Number Coverage | Compatible brands: Select Frigidaire, Electrolux, and Kenmore refrigerators | Universal fit: No | Installation: Built-in wiring harness; unplug power before installation | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Frigidaire EFIC117 Stainless Steel Ice Maker, 26 lb/day, Copper Finish |  | Best for a Statement Countertop Finish | Model: EFIC117-SSCOPPER-COM | Daily ice production: Up to 26 lb | Ice cycle: Nine cubes every seven minutes | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Frigidaire Portable Countertop Bullet Ice Maker, 26 lb per Day, Black Stainless Steel |  | Best for Flexible Countertop Placement | Model: EFIC120-BLKSS-SC | Daily ice production: Up to 26 lb | Ice cycle: Nine cubes about every seven minutes | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Frigidaire EFIC117-SS Portable Countertop Ice Maker |  | Best Compact Stainless Pick | Model: EFIC117-SS | Daily ice production: Up to 26 lb | Ice cycle: Nine cubes every seven minutes | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Frigidaire Countertop Bullet Ice Maker, 26 lb/Day, Stainless Steel |  | Best for a Simpler Serving Setup | Model: EFIC121/EFIC123 | Daily ice production: Up to 26 lb | Ice cycle: Nine cubes every seven minutes | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| frigidaire ice maker | Model | Dimensions |
|---|---|---|
| Frigidaire EFIC128AMZBLK Compa | EFIC128AMZBLK | 13 x 11 x 12.5 inches |
| Frigidaire IM116000 Ice Maker | IM116000 | — |
| Frigidaire Gallery EFIC255 Cou | EFIC255-NAVY | 14.6 x 10 x 16.75 inches |
| Frigidaire 241798231 Ice Maker | 241798231 | — |
| Frigidaire Countertop Chewable | EFIC22BAMZ | Listed as 11.65 x 16.93 x 20.87 inches and 12 x 9.5 x 14 inches |
| Kitchen Basics 101 Ice Maker R | — | 4.5 × 4.75 × 11.3 inches |
| Frigidaire Touchscreen Nugget | EFIC2320BLK | 16.75 × 11.75 × 20.25 inches (D × W × H) |
| Frigidaire Gallery Countertop | EFIC165 | 16.75 × 11.75 × 20.25 inches |
| Frigidaire EFIC117 Portable Co | EFIC117-SSRED-COM | 13 × 9 × 12 inches (D × W × H) |
| Frigidaire Nugget Ice Maker | EFIC255-CREAM | 14.6 × 10 × 16.75 inches (D × W × H) |
| Ice Maker Replacement for Sele | — | — |
| Frigidaire EFIC117 Stainless S | EFIC117-SSCOPPER-COM | 13 × 9 × 13 in (D × W × H) |
| Frigidaire Portable Countertop | EFIC120-BLKSS-SC | 15 × 11 × 14.5 in (D × W × H) |
| Frigidaire EFIC117-SS Portable | EFIC117-SS | 9 × 13 × 13 in (D × W × H) |
| Frigidaire Countertop Bullet I | EFIC121/EFIC123 | 13.5 × 10 × 14 in (D × W × H) |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Frigidaire EFIC128AMZBLK Compact Countertop Ice Maker, Black
The EFIC128AMZBLK suits buyers who want a compact machine for ordinary ice without the footprint or specialty-ice focus of the nugget models. It makes 9 cubes every 5–6 minutes, with a stated daily capacity of up to 26 pounds, so it can replenish a drink station steadily rather than fill a large bin all at once. At 13 x 11 x 12.5 inches, it is smaller than the Frigidaire Gallery EFIC255, but it produces conventional ice rather than chewable nuggets. The viewing window and low-water and full-basket alerts make routine use easier. Its main limitation is shared by many portable countertop makers: it does not keep ice frozen. I’d choose it for occasional drinks and move finished ice to a freezer; buyers who want nugget ice should look at the EFIC255 instead.
Pros:- Produces 9 cubes per cycle in about 5–6 minutes
- Up to 26 pounds of stated daily ice production
- Compact, portable footprint with a viewing window
- Alerts for a full basket and low water
Cons:- Does not keep produced ice frozen
- Ice needs to be transferred to a freezer promptly
- Makes conventional cubes rather than nugget ice
Best for: Apartment dwellers and small households who want a compact countertop source of conventional ice for drinks.
Not ideal for: People who need chewable nugget ice or want a machine that stores ice frozen for later use.
- Model:EFIC128AMZBLK
- Type:Countertop portable ice maker
- Color:Black
- Daily ice capacity:Up to 26 lb
- Ice per cycle:9 cubes
- Cycle time:5–6 minutes
- Dimensions:13 x 11 x 12.5 inches
- Alerts:Full basket and low water
Our verdict“Choose this compact Frigidaire when quick batches of conventional ice matter more than nugget texture or built-in frozen storage.”
Frigidaire IM116000 Ice Maker Assembly Kit for Refrigerators
The IM116000 is a repair part, not a countertop appliance, so it belongs on this list for owners restoring ice production inside a compatible Frigidaire refrigerator. As a genuine Frigidaire assembly engineered to the manufacturer’s specifications, it is a more direct replacement route than choosing a portable machine such as the EFIC128AMZBLK, which takes up counter space and requires manual ice transfers. That convenience depends on compatibility: I would verify the refrigerator’s exact model before ordering rather than assume the assembly fits because the brand matches. Installation is recommended for an experienced repair person, and the listed tools and safety gear point to a job beyond a simple plug-in setup. Its stated 4.7-pound capacity is not comparable to the daily output figures for countertop makers. This makes the most sense when the refrigerator is otherwise suitable and the goal is to restore its built-in ice function.
Pros:- Genuine Frigidaire replacement assembly
- Engineered to the manufacturer’s specifications
- Avoids adding a separate countertop ice machine
- Includes one ice maker assembly
Cons:- Compatibility must be checked against the exact refrigerator model
- Installation is recommended for an experienced repair person
- Requires tools and safety gear rather than simple countertop setup
Best for: Frigidaire refrigerator owners who have confirmed their appliance model is compatible and want a genuine replacement assembly.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking a ready-to-use countertop ice maker or anyone unable to verify refrigerator compatibility or manage a repair installation.
- Model:IM116000
- Item type:Ice maker assembly
- Color:White
- Unit count:1
- Capacity:4.7 pounds
- Wattage:150 watts
- Package weight:4.67 lb
- Installation skill level:Experienced repair person recommended
- Tools listed:1/4-inch nut driver, adjustable wrench, gloves, safety glasses
Our verdict“Pick the IM116000 to restore ice production in a confirmed-compatible Frigidaire refrigerator, not as a substitute for a portable ice maker.”
Frigidaire Gallery EFIC255 Countertop Nugget Ice Maker, 44 lb per Day, Navy
For buyers who want soft, chewable nugget ice and a stronger production ceiling, the Gallery EFIC255 is the most capable countertop choice in this group. It is rated for up to 44 pounds per day, ahead of the 33-pound EFIC22BAMZ, and its first batch takes about 10–15 minutes. That output suits gatherings or households that use nugget ice throughout the day, though the 3-pound bin means the machine makes ice faster than it can store a large reserve. A self-cleaning function, viewing window, drawer access, and included scoop and drip tray make day-to-day handling more considered than on the simpler EFIC128AMZBLK. The tradeoff is that the reservoir still needs manual filling, and the unit is larger than a basic compact ice maker. I’d choose it for production and nugget texture, not for unattended frozen storage.
Pros:- Produces soft, chewable nugget ice
- Up to 44 pounds of ice production per day
- Self-cleaning function and viewing window
- Includes an ice bin, scoop, and drip tray
Cons:- The ice bin holds only 3 pounds
- Water reservoir requires manual filling
- Larger than simpler compact countertop options
Best for: Nugget-ice fans hosting gatherings or serving a household that uses chewable ice throughout the day.
Not ideal for: Buyers with limited counter space, those who want a large ready-to-serve ice reserve, or anyone unwilling to refill a water reservoir.
- Model:EFIC255-NAVY
- Ice type:Chewable nugget ice
- Color:Navy
- Ice production per day:Up to 44 lb
- Ice bin capacity:3 lb
- Time to first ice:10–15 minutes
- Dimensions:14.6 x 10 x 16.75 inches
- Wattage and voltage:500 watts; 120 volts
- Warranty:1-year limited warranty
Our verdict“Choose the EFIC255 if high daily output and nugget texture outweigh the small bin and manual reservoir filling.”
Frigidaire 241798231 Ice Maker Assembly Kit for Refrigerators
The 241798231 assembly is a targeted refrigerator repair option, with the supplied data naming the Frigidaire FFHS2322MS as a compatible model. That makes it a more specific fit than the IM116000 listing, which calls for buyers to verify their refrigerator model without naming one here. I would still check the appliance manual and model details before purchase; the listed compatibility is not a reason to assume it fits other Frigidaire refrigerators. Unlike the EFIC128AMZBLK countertop maker, this part restores built-in ice production without adding a separate machine to the kitchen. The tradeoff is the repair itself: installation is recommended for experienced DIYers and requires a 1/4-inch nut driver and safety gear. Its stated production of 4 pounds per day is a replacement-part specification, not a reason to expect countertop-style batch output.
Pros:- Genuine Frigidaire replacement assembly
- Manufacturer-specification design for a refrigerator repair
- Compatible refrigerator model is specifically identified in the product data
- Compact assembly dimensions for installation inside a refrigerator
Cons:- Compatibility should be confirmed against the appliance manual
- Installation is recommended for experienced DIYers
- Requires tools and safety gear, unlike a portable countertop unit
Best for: Owners of a Frigidaire FFHS2322MS who have confirmed the assembly matches their refrigerator and are comfortable with DIY repair.
Not ideal for: People with a different or unverified refrigerator model, or shoppers who need a plug-in countertop ice maker.
- Model:241798231
- Part type:Ice maker assembly
- Compatible refrigerator model:Frigidaire FFHS2322MS
- Ice production per day:4 lb
- Wattage and voltage:115 watts; 120 volts
- Item dimensions:11.75 x 4.62 x 4.12 inches (D x W x H)
- Package weight:3.23 lb
- Materials:Metal and plastic
- Installation tools:1/4-inch nut driver, gloves, safety glasses
Our verdict“Choose this assembly for a confirmed FFHS2322MS repair when you want built-in refrigerator ice rather than a separate countertop machine.”
Frigidaire Countertop Chewable Nugget Ice Maker
The EFIC22BAMZ brings chewable nugget ice to a countertop without a water hookup, making it a more accessible choice than a refrigerator assembly such as the IM116000. Its first ice arrives in about 10–15 minutes, and the stated daily output reaches 33 pounds—less than the Gallery EFIC255’s 44-pound capacity, but a better match for buyers who do not need the higher production ceiling. The 3-pound basket keeps the footprint of stored ice modest, so regular use means serving or transferring batches rather than relying on a large reserve. It also does not keep ice frozen, an important distinction for anyone expecting a freezer-like bin. The listed dimensions differ between the description and product information, so I would check the machine’s actual measurements against available counter space before buying.
Pros:- Produces soft, chewable nugget ice
- First ice in about 10–15 minutes
- No water hookup required
- Up to 33 pounds of stated daily production
Cons:- Does not keep produced ice frozen
- Basket holds only 3 pounds at a time
- Two different dimension listings make counter-fit checks necessary
Best for: Nugget-ice fans in smaller households who want a portable, no-hookup machine and do not need the Gallery EFIC255’s higher daily output.
Not ideal for: People who need a large ice reserve, frozen storage, or precise fit assurance without confirming the conflicting listed dimensions.
- Model:EFIC22BAMZ
- Ice type:Chewable nugget ice
- Ice production per day:Up to 33 lb
- Ice basket capacity:3 lb (2.5 quarts)
- Time to first ice:10–15 minutes
- Voltage and wattage:120 volts; 200 watts
- Dimensions:Listed as 11.65 x 16.93 x 20.87 inches and 12 x 9.5 x 14 inches
- Warranty:1 year
- Included components:Machine, scoop, manual
Our verdict“Pick the EFIC22BAMZ for portable nugget ice at a lower stated output than the EFIC255, provided you can manage small batches and freezer transfers.”
Kitchen Basics 101 Ice Maker Replacement for Electrolux and Frigidaire Refrigerators
This is the repair-focused pick in a lineup otherwise led by countertop machines: it replaces an existing ice maker rather than adding a separate source of ice. Its 8-cube cycle and automatic shut-off arm suit owners whose compatible refrigerator has stopped making or controlling ice. Compared with the Frigidaire EFIC117, it won’t provide a portable, self-contained appliance; its value depends on matching the refrigerator’s model and the listed replacement part numbers. That model-specific fit is the main tradeoff, so I’d check the appliance’s parts information before ordering rather than assume all Frigidaire refrigerators are compatible. The one-year warranty adds a defined coverage period, but replacing the assembly may not resolve problems caused by other faults, debris, or leaks.
Pros:- Makes 8 cubes per cycle
- Automatic shut-off arm helps stop production when the bin is full
- Compatible with select Electrolux and Frigidaire refrigerators
- Includes a one-year warranty
Cons:- Fits only specific refrigerator models, so compatibility must be verified
- Replacing the assembly may not fix ice issues caused by other parts, debris, or leaks
Best for: Owners of a compatible Electrolux or Frigidaire refrigerator who want to replace a failed ice maker assembly rather than buy a countertop unit.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking a stand-alone ice maker, or refrigerator owners who have not confirmed model and part-number compatibility.
- Cubes per cycle:8
- Shut-off:Automatic arm
- Dimensions:4.5 × 4.75 × 11.3 inches
- Compatible brands:Select Electrolux and Frigidaire refrigerators
- Warranty:1 year
- Replacement part numbers:241798201, 5304456671, 241642501, 241642503A, 241798211, 241798231, 241642511, 241798209, 3206327, 3206329, 5303320545, 5304445222, 5304456669, PS10057209, AP6332951, 5304456672, 241798220, 75304445222, 75304456669, 75304456671, 75304456672, 4591526, PS12364147
Our verdict“Choose this replacement assembly if your refrigerator is confirmed compatible and you want to restore built-in ice production instead of adding a countertop machine.”
Frigidaire Touchscreen Nugget Ice Maker, 33 lb Daily Capacity, Slate
The EFIC2320BLK suits buyers who want chewable nugget ice with a clear, touchscreen-led control experience, but don’t need the highest output in this group. It can make up to 33 pounds per day, while the Frigidaire Gallery EFIC165 and EFIC255-CREAM are rated for 44 pounds. That lower capacity may be a sensible match for lighter daily use, though its 1.2 L storage means you’ll need to keep up with batches rather than treat the bin as long-term storage. The manual-fill tank avoids a plumbing connection, and the 20-minute cleaning cycle adds a regular maintenance aid. In return, this model still needs counter space and water refills, and its smaller bin is a more noticeable limitation than on the 3-pound-bin alternatives.
Pros:- Produces soft, chewable nugget ice
- First batch is ready in about 10–15 minutes
- Manual-fill tank needs no plumbing connection
- Includes a 20-minute automatic cleaning cycle and status indicators
Cons:- Daily production is lower than the 44-pound EFIC165 and EFIC255-CREAM
- The 1.2 L ice storage capacity calls for frequent serving or transfers
Best for: Households that prefer chewable nugget ice, want touchscreen controls, and use less ice than a 44-pound-per-day machine can produce.
Not ideal for: Frequent entertainers or high-volume users who want the greater daily output and 3-pound storage bin of the EFIC165 or EFIC255-CREAM.
- Model:EFIC2320BLK
- Daily ice production:33 lbs.
- Water tank capacity:1.8 L
- Ice storage capacity:1.2 L (approximately 0.7 kg)
- First ice:10–15 minutes
- Self-cleaning cycle:20 minutes
- Dimensions:16.75 × 11.75 × 20.25 inches (D × W × H)
- Power and voltage:192 W; 120 V
- Warranty:1-year limited
Our verdict“Pick the EFIC2320BLK for touchscreen-controlled nugget ice and moderate household demand, but choose a 44-pound model if you regularly need larger batches.”
Frigidaire Gallery Countertop Nugget Ice Maker, 44 lbs per Day, Black
For buyers whose priority is a larger daily supply of chewable ice, the EFIC165 raises the ceiling to 44 pounds per day, compared with 33 pounds from the touchscreen EFIC2320BLK. Its 3-pound bin also holds more than that model’s 1.2 L storage, giving you more ice ready to serve at once. The first batch takes about 10–15 minutes, and the built-in reservoir means no plumbing hookup is needed. Automatic cleaning, a scoop, and a drip tray round out a convenient countertop setup. The tradeoff is the same practical limit found on the EFIC255-CREAM: a 3-pound bin is still small compared with the advertised daily output, so steady supply depends on emptying the bin and making room for more. Its 500-watt draw is another spec to weigh against lower-power alternatives.
Pros:- Rated to produce up to 44 pounds of nugget ice per day
- 3-pound bin offers more ready-to-serve ice than the EFIC2320BLK
- First batch takes about 10–15 minutes
- Automatic cleaning and included scoop and drip tray support routine use
Cons:- The 3-pound bin is much smaller than its daily production capacity
- Uses 500 watts, more than the 192-watt EFIC2320BLK
Best for: Nugget-ice fans who serve several people and value higher daily production and a larger ready-to-scoop bin.
Not ideal for: Buyers with limited counter space, low ice demand, or a preference for a larger reserve bin that can hold more than 3 pounds.
- Model:EFIC165
- Ice production per day:Up to 44 lbs.
- Ice bin capacity:3 lbs.
- First batch time:About 10–15 minutes
- Power and voltage:500 W; 120 V
- Dimensions:16.75 × 11.75 × 20.25 inches
- Refrigerant:R600a
- Included components:Ice maker, ice bin, ice scoop, and drip tray
Our verdict“Choose the EFIC165 if you want a high-output nugget maker with a larger countertop bin, and can manage frequent bin turnover.”
Frigidaire EFIC117 Portable Countertop Ice Maker, Red Stainless Steel
The EFIC117 is the compact choice here for buyers who want straightforward bullet-shaped ice rather than nugget ice. At 13 × 9 × 12 inches, it has a much smaller footprint than the EFIC165, which stands 20.25 inches tall. It also starts producing ice in about 7 minutes, with nine cubes per cycle, making it a practical fit for a small kitchen, bar, or office where quick batches matter more than chewable texture. The 26-pound daily capacity is below the nugget models’ 33- and 44-pound ratings, and the 1.5-pound basket and 2.1-quart tank mean this machine needs regular attention when several people are using it. Its two ice sizes add flexibility, but bullet ice won’t suit every drink or glass.
Pros:- Compact 13 × 9 × 12-inch footprint
- Makes nine cubes about every 7 minutes
- Two ice-size options and digital LED controls
- Transparent window, drain plug, and included scoop aid monitoring and cleanup
Cons:- 2.1-quart tank and 1.5-pound basket require frequent refilling and emptying
- Bullet-shaped ice differs from the chewable nugget ice produced by the EFIC165 and EFIC255-CREAM
Best for: People with limited counter space who want fast batches of bullet ice for a small household, office, or home bar.
Not ideal for: Nugget-ice fans or high-volume households that need a larger basket and higher daily production.
- Model:EFIC117-SSRED-COM
- Ice type:Bullet-shaped
- Daily ice production:Up to 26 lbs.
- Ice cycle:9 cubes in about 7 minutes
- Water tank capacity:2.1 qt
- Ice basket capacity:1.5 lbs.
- Dimensions:13 × 9 × 12 inches (D × W × H)
- Power and voltage:500 W; 115 V
- Color:Red stainless steel
Our verdict“Pick the EFIC117 for a small space and fast bullet ice, but skip it if you want nugget texture or substantial ready-to-serve storage.”
Frigidaire Nugget Ice Maker, 44 lb Daily Capacity, Cream
The EFIC255-CREAM pairs 44-pound daily production with a smaller listed footprint than the Gallery EFIC165: it measures 14.6 × 10 × 16.75 inches, while the EFIC165 is 16.75 × 11.75 × 20.25 inches. That makes the cream model the more space-conscious choice between these two high-output nugget makers, without giving up the stated daily capacity. It also starts a batch in about 10 minutes and adds a viewing window, touch controls, and automatic cleaning. Both models have a 3-pound bin, so neither can hold a full day’s production at once; plan to empty the bin as it fills. Manual reservoir refills are another routine task, and the EFIC165 includes a scoop and drip tray in its listed components, while those extras aren’t specified here.
Pros:- Produces up to 44 pounds of chewable nugget ice per day
- Smaller listed dimensions than the Gallery EFIC165
- First batch is ready in about 10 minutes
- Viewing window, touch controls, and automatic cleaning add convenience
Cons:- The 3-pound bin holds only a small fraction of a day’s stated production
- Requires manual reservoir refills
- Listed specs do not confirm the scoop and drip tray included with the EFIC165
Best for: Nugget-ice buyers who want 44-pound daily output but have less counter room than the larger EFIC165 footprint requires.
Not ideal for: People who want a large reserve of ice between servings, a plumbed water supply, or confirmed included accessories such as a scoop and drip tray.
- Model:EFIC255-CREAM
- Daily ice production:Up to 44 lbs.
- Ice bin capacity:3 lbs.
- First batch time:About 10 minutes
- Dimensions:14.6 × 10 × 16.75 inches (D × W × H)
- Power and voltage:500 W; 115 V
- Refrigerant:R410a
- Warranty:1-year limited
Our verdict“Choose the EFIC255-CREAM if you want high-output nugget ice in a smaller listed footprint and are comfortable refilling and emptying it regularly.”
Ice Maker Replacement for Select Frigidaire, Electrolux, and Kenmore Refrigerators
This replacement assembly is the refrigerator-repair pick in a group otherwise centered on countertop ice makers. Its main advantage is compatibility with a long list of part numbers across select Frigidaire, Electrolux, and Kenmore refrigerators, which may help when matching an older unit. The built-in wiring harness is included, so buyers do not need to source that component separately. Compared with Frigidaire’s IM116000 kit, this model’s listed part-number range gives another path for owners whose existing assembly matches one of its references. The limitation is equally important: it is not a universal replacement, and a broad list does not guarantee fit. I would verify the refrigerator’s exact model and existing part number before ordering; countertop models such as the EFIC117-SS are the better choice for adding ice without repairing a refrigerator.
Pros:- Covers numerous listed replacement part numbers
- Compatible with select Frigidaire, Electrolux, and Kenmore refrigerators
- Includes a built-in wiring harness
- Designed for installation as a replacement assembly
Cons:- Not a universal fit; refrigerator compatibility must be verified
- Installation requires unplugging power and working with refrigerator wiring
Best for: Owners of select Frigidaire, Electrolux, or Kenmore refrigerators who can match their existing assembly to a listed part number.
Not ideal for: Buyers who want a standalone countertop ice maker or cannot confirm their refrigerator’s model and part-number compatibility.
- Compatible brands:Select Frigidaire, Electrolux, and Kenmore refrigerators
- Universal fit:No
- Installation:Built-in wiring harness; unplug power before installation
- Part numbers:241798224, 241798201, 5304456671, 241642501, 241642503A, 241798211, 241798231, 241642511, 241798209, 5303320545, 5304445222, 5304456669, PS10057209, AP6332951, 5304456672, 241798220, 75304445222, 75304456669, 75304456671, 75304456672, 4591526, PS12085911, 3206327, 3206329
Our verdict“Choose this assembly only when your refrigerator model or current part number matches its compatibility list.”
Frigidaire EFIC117 Stainless Steel Ice Maker, 26 lb/day, Copper Finish
The EFIC117 in copper stainless is the style-led choice among these compact Frigidaire machines. Its 26-pound daily output and cycle of nine cubes about every seven minutes match the practical pace of the black-stainless EFIC120, while the copper finish gives this model a more distinctive presence in a kitchen, bar, or office. A 2.1-quart tank means less frequent topping up than the EFIC121/EFIC123’s 1.9-quart reservoir, though none of these countertop units connects to a water line. The tradeoff is the familiar small-batch workflow: the basket holds just 1.5 pounds, so steady entertaining calls for regular transfers to a freezer. Its bullet ice also differs from the chewable nugget ice available in Frigidaire’s nugget models, making this a poor match for buyers set on that texture.
Pros:- Distinctive copper-stainless finish
- Produces up to 26 pounds of bullet ice per day
- Makes nine cubes in about seven minutes with two size options
- 2.1-quart tank, viewing window, and drain plug support routine use and cleaning
Cons:- The 1.5-pound basket needs frequent emptying during sustained use
- Bullet-shaped cubes do not provide the chew of Frigidaire nugget models
- Water tank must be refilled manually
Best for: Buyers who want a countertop Frigidaire ice maker with a copper-stainless finish for a kitchen, bar, or office.
Not ideal for: Households needing a large on-machine ice reserve, automatic water-line filling, or chewable nugget ice.
- Model:EFIC117-SSCOPPER-COM
- Daily ice production:Up to 26 lb
- Ice cycle:Nine cubes every seven minutes
- Water tank capacity:2.1 qt
- Ice basket capacity:1.5 lb
- Dimensions:13 × 9 × 13 in (D × W × H)
- Power:1000 W, 115 V
- Ice type and controls:Bullet-shaped ice; digital LED size selection
Our verdict“Pick the copper EFIC117 for its finish and larger listed tank, provided bullet ice and frequent basket emptying suit your routine.”
Frigidaire Portable Countertop Bullet Ice Maker, 26 lb per Day, Black Stainless Steel
This EFIC120 makes the most sense for buyers who want a portable ice maker with clear controls and a darker finish, rather than a plumbed-in appliance. It delivers up to 26 pounds per day, with nine bullet cubes per roughly seven-minute cycle and two size choices—similar production to the EFIC117-SS in standard stainless. The viewing window and digital panel make it easy to check progress without opening the unit, and the drain plug helps with cleanup. Compared with the EFIC121/EFIC123, it has a slightly larger 2.1-quart tank, but it still requires manual refilling and its basket holds only 1.5 pounds. At 15 × 11 × 14.5 inches, it also takes more counter space than the compact-dimension EFIC117-SS listing, so measure the intended spot before choosing.
Pros:- Produces up to 26 pounds of bullet ice per day
- Nine-cube cycles take about seven minutes and offer two sizes
- Digital controls and a viewing window simplify monitoring
- 2.1-quart tank and drain plug support filling and cleanup
Cons:- The 1.5-pound basket fills quickly during heavy use
- Water tank requires manual refilling
- Larger listed footprint than the EFIC117-SS
Best for: People who want a portable black-stainless ice maker for occasional hosting, an office, or a kitchen with room for its footprint.
Not ideal for: Buyers with very limited counter space, a need for unattended water supply, or demand for a large stored batch.
- Model:EFIC120-BLKSS-SC
- Daily ice production:Up to 26 lb
- Ice cycle:Nine cubes about every seven minutes
- Ice options:Bullet ice; two sizes
- Water tank capacity:2.1 qt
- Ice basket capacity:1.5 lb
- Dimensions:15 × 11 × 14.5 in (D × W × H)
- Power:1000 W, 120 V
- Included components:Ice maker, ice scoop, ice basket
Our verdict“Choose the EFIC120 if its black-stainless look and 2.1-quart tank appeal and you have counter space for its larger footprint.”
Frigidaire EFIC117-SS Portable Countertop Ice Maker
For a buyer prioritizing a smaller listed footprint, the EFIC117-SS offers a straightforward stainless countertop setup: 9 × 13 × 13 inches, a 2.1-quart water tank, and output rated up to 26 pounds per day. It makes nine bullet cubes every seven minutes and provides two sizes, much like the black-stainless EFIC120, but the listed dimensions are notably more compact. The digital controls, viewing window, and drain plug cover the basics without adding a more elaborate feature set. Its limits are shared by most machines here: the 1.5-pound basket is a temporary holding spot, not long-term storage, and the tank needs manual refilling. Compared with the EFIC121/EFIC123, this model has the larger listed reservoir, though that other unit may appeal to buyers who prefer its different dimensions and included basket.
Pros:- Compact listed dimensions for a countertop machine
- Up to 26 pounds of bullet ice per day with two size choices
- 2.1-quart water tank
- Viewing window, digital controls, and drain plug simplify operation and cleaning
Cons:- The 1.5-pound basket needs regular emptying
- Manual tank refills are required
- Bullet ice differs from the chewable nugget ice offered by other Frigidaire models
Best for: Apartment dwellers or office users seeking a compact stainless countertop ice maker with a larger tank than the EFIC121/EFIC123.
Not ideal for: People who need a large ice reserve, automatic water filling, or nugget-style ice for chewable drinks.
- Model:EFIC117-SS
- Daily ice production:Up to 26 lb
- Ice cycle:Nine cubes every seven minutes
- Ice options:Bullet-shaped ice; two sizes
- Water tank capacity:2.1 qt
- Ice basket capacity:1.5 lb
- Dimensions:9 × 13 × 13 in (D × W × H)
- Power:105 W, 120 V
- Warranty:1 year
Our verdict“The EFIC117-SS is a sensible fit for buyers who want a compact stainless unit and can manage frequent basket transfers.”
Frigidaire Countertop Bullet Ice Maker, 26 lb/Day, Stainless Steel
The EFIC121/EFIC123 is a practical pick for buyers who want the core Frigidaire countertop routine without a larger water reservoir. It produces up to 26 pounds per day, with nine bullet cubes ready in about seven minutes and two size options—matching the headline output of the EFIC117-SS and EFIC120. Its 1.9-quart tank is smaller than the 2.1-quart tanks in those two models, so expect somewhat more frequent refills if ice demand is steady. Digital controls, a viewing window, drain plug, basket, and scoop make it ready for serving and cleanup. Compared with the EFIC117-SS, this model’s listed dimensions are different rather than clearly more compact, so I would check the available counter area instead of choosing by name alone. Like its siblings, it cannot hold much ice in the machine while production continues.
Pros:- Produces up to 26 pounds of bullet ice per day
- Nine-cube cycles take about seven minutes, with two ice sizes
- Includes a basket, scoop, and drain plug
- Digital controls and viewing window make operation easier to monitor
Cons:- The 1.9-quart tank is smaller than the 2.1-quart tanks on the EFIC117 models
- Manual water refilling is required
- The small countertop basket cannot store a large supply
Best for: Small households or occasional hosts who want a stainless Frigidaire machine with basic controls, a scoop, and a countertop ice supply.
Not ideal for: Frequent entertainers who want fewer water refills or a larger basket, or buyers seeking nugget-shaped ice.
- Model:EFIC121/EFIC123
- Daily ice production:Up to 26 lb
- Ice cycle:Nine cubes every seven minutes
- Ice type and sizes:Bullet-shaped; two sizes
- Water tank capacity:1.9 qt
- Dimensions:13.5 × 10 × 14 in (D × W × H)
- Power:105 W, 115 V
- Refrigerant:R134a
- Warranty:1 year parts and labor
Our verdict“Choose the EFIC121/EFIC123 for a basic stainless countertop setup if its smaller tank and limited onboard storage fit your use.”
How We Picked
I grouped these Frigidaire ice makers by what they actually do: countertop bullet-ice machines, countertop nugget-ice machines, and refrigerator replacement assemblies. I weighed stated daily output against intended use, ice style, countertop or installation demands, ease of operation, and the maintenance a buyer should expect from a machine that makes and stores ice. Compatibility mattered especially for replacement parts, where a familiar brand name does not by itself confirm a match for a specific refrigerator.
The ranking favors options with a clear role and useful combination of capacity, usability, and versatility. That puts a high-output nugget machine first for buyers seeking a standalone appliance, while compact bullet models rank well for simpler needs. Replacement kits sit lower in an all-purpose roundup because they only help owners with a compatible refrigerator and a repair need; within that group, the right part number matters more than countertop features. Similar finishes and capacities are separated by controls, stated use, and how clearly each listing identifies its purpose.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Frigidaire Ice Makers
Before choosing among Frigidaire ice makers, decide whether you need a countertop appliance or a refrigerator repair component. Then match ice style and real household demand to the machine, rather than treating a daily-capacity figure as the only measure of fit.
Choose Nugget or Bullet Ice by How You Serve It
Nugget ice is a good match for people who prefer small, chewable pieces in soft drinks and other cold beverages. Bullet ice is a more straightforward choice for everyday chilling, and it appears across several compact Frigidaire countertop options in this lineup. Do not assume one style is universally better: the shape affects the texture of a drink and how you use the ice, not just the machine’s appearance. If multiple people in the household have different preferences, consider which style gets used most often. A common mistake is buying a nugget model for its popularity without checking whether its larger footprint and care routine suit the kitchen. Choose by routine first, then compare finishes and controls among models that make the right kind of ice.
Treat Daily Capacity as a Production Claim, Not Storage
Daily output describes ice made over time, not necessarily how much the machine can hold at once. A countertop unit may need regular attention even when its stated daily capacity sounds ample, since ice can be used faster than it accumulates or may need transferring to a freezer. Think about when your household needs ice: a steady stream for daily drinks differs from a large amount for a gathering. Check the product details for basket capacity, cycle timing, and water-reservoir information rather than relying on the headline pounds-per-day figure alone. Buyers often overestimate production needs and end up giving valuable counter space to a machine that runs more than necessary. A smaller-output option can be the more sensible fit if you use ice intermittently.
Measure the Counter and Plan for Water and Heat
Countertop fit involves more than the appliance’s width and depth. Leave room to open or remove the basket, reach the controls, add water, and provide the clearance the manufacturer specifies for ventilation. Consider the location of an outlet and whether the machine will sit near a sink or require you to carry water to it. Ice makers also release heat while operating, so a cramped cabinet or enclosed shelf may be a poor location even if the unit physically fits. Before ordering, compare the full dimensions with your available space and include room for routine access. This check matters especially when moving up from a compact bullet machine to a larger nugget model.
Check Refrigerator Compatibility Before Buying a Kit
Replacement assemblies are not universal simply because a listing names Frigidaire, Electrolux, or Kenmore. Confirm the refrigerator’s full model number and compare it with the part’s compatibility information; similar-looking assemblies can differ in connectors, mounting, or the refrigerators they fit. If a listing is unclear, verify fit with the manufacturer or a qualified parts seller before ordering. Also identify whether the problem is actually the ice maker assembly or another part of the refrigerator’s water or control system. Buying the wrong kit can add delay without fixing the fault. For a repair purchase, model-specific fit is a better deciding factor than broad brand coverage.
Compare Controls, Cleaning, and Ongoing Attention
Usability and upkeep shape whether a countertop ice maker remains convenient after the first few batches. Look at how the controls are laid out, how easily the basket and water areas can be reached, and what the manufacturer says about cleaning and descaling. A touchscreen may appeal to buyers who want a more modern interface, but it does not replace checking the cleaning instructions. Nugget machines and bullet machines can have different care needs, so use the manual for the exact model rather than assuming shared brand means identical maintenance. Factor in how often you are willing to empty, refill, and clean the unit. A model that fits your habits is more useful than one chosen on output alone.
Pay for Features That Match a Specific Need
Spend on a clear benefit, not a finish or capacity number you will rarely use. A nugget model makes sense when that ice texture is a priority, while a compact bullet unit may cover everyday drinks with less counter commitment. A premium-feeling control panel or distinctive finish can matter if the machine stays on display, but it should come after footprint, ice type, and cleaning. For a refrigerator owner, spending on a replacement kit only makes sense once compatibility and diagnosis are clear. Compare variants by their confirmed specifications rather than assuming that a different color means different performance. This approach helps avoid paying for a feature that does not change your day-to-day use.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I choose a Frigidaire nugget ice maker or a bullet ice maker?
Choose by the texture you prefer and how much counter space you can spare. Nugget machines in this lineup are aimed at people who want chewable ice, with several models listing 44 pounds of daily production and one touchscreen version listing 33 pounds. Bullet models, including EFIC117 variants, list 26 pounds per day and offer a more compact-style countertop role. Those figures are not a direct measure of basket storage or how quickly you can get a first batch. Check the machine’s dimensions and care instructions alongside ice style before deciding.
Can I use a Frigidaire refrigerator ice maker kit in any Frigidaire refrigerator?
No. A kit’s brand association does not establish that it fits every refrigerator from that brand. Match the complete refrigerator model number against the kit’s compatibility list, and check connector and installation details where available. This is especially relevant when comparing part numbers such as IM116000 and 241798231, which are distinct listings. If you cannot confirm a fit, ask the manufacturer or a parts specialist before ordering.
Does a 44-pound daily capacity mean the nugget ice maker stores 44 pounds at once?
No. A daily capacity is a production figure over time, not the amount held in the basket at one moment. The machine may need to be emptied or the ice moved to a freezer as you use it, depending on its storage design and instructions. Check basket capacity and production-cycle details in the specific listing or manual. For occasional use, storage and convenience may matter more than the largest daily-output claim.
How do I decide between the different EFIC117 finishes?
Start by confirming that the model and listed specifications meet your needs, then choose a finish that suits where the machine will sit. The EFIC117 options in this roundup include red stainless steel, copper, and stainless steel variants, while another portable bullet model is listed in black stainless steel. The stated 26-pound daily output appears across several compact options, so a finish change alone should not be treated as a performance upgrade. Compare dimensions, controls, and included details in each exact listing before choosing by appearance.
Is a countertop ice maker a better choice than replacing my refrigerator’s ice maker?
It depends on whether the refrigerator is otherwise working and whether its ice-maker fault has been diagnosed. A compatible replacement assembly can restore the built-in setup without adding a separate appliance, but the correct part number and installation requirements matter. A countertop machine gives you an independent source of ice, though it takes counter space and needs water, emptying, and cleaning. If the refrigerator’s water supply or controls are the real issue, replacing only the ice maker assembly may not solve it. Confirm the fault and compare the repair effort with the ongoing countertop routine.
Conclusion
For most buyers seeking a standalone machine, I’d start with the Frigidaire Gallery EFIC255: its stated 44-pound daily output and nugget-ice format give it the broadest appeal among this roundup’s countertop picks. The EFIC117 bullet-ice models are my value-minded direction for buyers who want a simpler, compact-style option, while first-time countertop buyers should favor a model whose size, controls, and cleaning requirements feel manageable over chasing maximum output. For a premium-leaning choice, compare the touchscreen nugget model with the Gallery units and choose based on interface, stated capacity, and fit rather than finish alone. If you need a refrigerator repair, the best specific choice is the compatible assembly—verify the model number before ordering any kit. In short: choose nugget ice for chewable texture, bullet ice for straightforward countertop use, and a replacement part only when fit and diagnosis are confirmed.
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
