Delicious Gelato

Why is My Sonic Ice Cream Gritty?




Affiliate Disclaimer

As an affiliate, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases. We get commissions for purchases made through links on this website from Amazon and other third parties.

There are a few reasons why your ice cream might have gotten gritty. These include over-churning, sugar, and trans fat. Luckily, there are some easy fixes. In this article, we’ll take a look at a few of them.


If you’ve ever tried refreezing Sonic ice cream, you know that it can have a grainy texture. This is because the lactose sugar in the ice cream crystallizes. The process occurs when small ice crystals melt and then refreeze. When this happens, large ice crystals form. Moisture and evaporation can also cause these crystals to form.

After refreezing your ice cream, you need to make sure you put it back into the freezer as soon as possible. If you leave it out for too long, you may risk exposing it to insects and bacteria. Also, eating melted and refreezed ice cream could lead to food poisoning. Once bacteria begin to grow, you can get a stomach ache, so be sure to scrape off the melted part before eating it.


Over-churning is a common problem with ice cream. When it is over-churned, it turns the base liquid into a solid before it has frozen. To fix this problem, increase the speed of churning the base.

Over-churning can also affect the texture of the ice cream. Too much churning will create large ice crystals, which will make the ice cream grittier. Also, over-churning can occur when the ice cream maker is not of a high quality.

Another way to check if your ice cream is over-churned is to monitor the melting time of your ice cream. A properly-churned ice cream should take about 15 to 20 minutes to melt completely. If it melts more quickly, it was over-churned and needs to be remade.


The gritty texture of Sonic ice cream can be a sign that the product has been stored too long. This can occur for several reasons. Specifically, when the ice cream is kept too long, it will form ice crystals on the surface and lose its creamy texture. It can also occur because the ice cream has been stored in a container with no air tight seal.

The texture of a Sonic milkshake can also be a cause of the gritty texture. The real vanilla ice cream in these drinks is blended with other ingredients to make it look more like a shake.

Trans fat

Despite its popularity, Sonic ice cream is not exactly healthy. There’s a lot of trans fat in the brand’s milkshakes, which makes the ice cream gritty and sandy. According to Yahoo!, the company’s products are among the most unhealthy fast food chains in the US. Also, Sonic’s chili is left sitting for long periods before making it to customers’ cars.

To create trans fat, manufacturers add hydrogen to vegetable oil. Some major chain restaurants have begun to remove partially hydrogenated oils from their products, but many other chains are still using them. Smaller restaurants are a bit slower to follow the trend.

Poor quality ice cream maker

A poor quality ice cream maker will often churn the ice cream more than is necessary. This can affect the texture of the ice cream. You want to make sure that your ice cream has small, hard curds. This will prevent the ice cream from becoming grainy. Also, a poor ice cream maker will pump air into the mixture, making it less creamy.

When you’re making ice cream in an ice cream maker, it’s important to read the instructions carefully. Don’t put the ice cream maker in the freezer upside down. If this happens, the coolant liquid will drain out of the compressor and cause your ice cream to fail to freeze.

About the author

Latest posts

  • Ninja Deluxe Ice Cream Maker Review (2023)

    Ninja Deluxe Ice Cream Maker Review (2023)

    Today, I’ll be sharing my thoughts and experiences with the Ninja NC501 CREAMi Deluxe Ice Cream Maker. As a huge fan of frozen treats, I was excited to try out this 11-in-1 machine that promises to make ice cream, sorbet, milkshakes, frozen drinks, and more! I’ve been using it for a while now, and here’s…

    Read more

  • Why Ice Cream Makes You Happy

    Why Ice Cream Makes You Happy

    Ice cream is one of life’s greatest pleasures. It’s sweet, creamy, and can make even the worst day seem better. But why does it make us so happy? Its effects go beyond just a sugary treat – there are some real psychological benefits to eating ice cream. In this article, we’ll explore why ice cream…

    Read more

  • What Is Ice Cream Custard

    What Is Ice Cream Custard

    Ice cream custard is one of those treats that I discovered by chance. On a sunny summer day, I stumbled upon a small ice cream shop tucked away in an alleyway near my home. Intrigued by the sweet smell wafting through the air, I decided to take a peek and see what they had to…

    Read more