TL;DR
Get baking supplies delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
The Kitchn editorial assistant Celia Funderburk says she tested nine gingerbread house kits and selected five for different priorities, including overall decorating, budget, young children, taste and decorating detail. Her report names Dylan’s Candy Bar, two Favorite Day kits, King Arthur Baking Company and Wilton; the supplied source gives detailed findings for three of the five picks.
The Kitchn’s Celia Funderburk tested nine gingerbread house kits and selected five for different needs, from an elaborate decorating session to an easier activity for young children. The product review names Dylan’s Candy Bar its overall pick, while two Favorite Day kits, King Arthur Baking Company and Wilton round out the list.
Funderburk said she began researching the comparison in September and assembled all nine kits herself. She tracked whether the icing held the structure together, how much candy came in each box, whether decorations were left over and whether gingerbread pieces were broken before assembly. The testing was intended to weigh the practical experience of building and decorating, not just the contents listed on the packaging.
The report calls the $65 Dylan’s Candy Bar kit the best overall, citing its pre-built house and range of decorations. Funderburk describes three icing colors, dot candies, rainbow belts, gumballs, cotton candy sticks and chocolate presents, with enough candy to snack on during decorating. She also identifies the price as a drawback: it was the most expensive kit among those tested.
For shoppers seeking a lower-cost option, the report recommends Favorite Day’s pre-built gingerbread house, which comes with three bags of candy and two icing colors. Funderburk praised the decorating space and said the roof in her box arrived broken. The other detailed pick, Favorite Day’s pre-built holiday coloring village, includes four iced houses, black stencils, food-safe color markers, a small bag of icing and candy. The report describes it as simple and relatively low-mess, but says the activity may be short.
Five Kits for Different Holiday Plans
The list gives shoppers a way to match a kit to the kind of gathering they want: a more decorated, candy-heavy centerpiece; a less expensive house that is ready to decorate; or a shared coloring activity that reduces assembly and icing work. Those differences matter when buyers are choosing for children, a group activity or a limited budget, rather than judging every box by the same standard.
The review also points to a practical risk with pre-built kits: a broken piece can undermine the convenience they promise. Funderburk’s report says her Favorite Day house arrived with a broken roof, though it does not establish how common shipping damage is. The experience is a reminder that the condition of a kit may affect the project, but the source provides no broader damage-rate data.
Products Worth Considering
Weber Searwood XL 600 Wood Pellet Smoker Grill, 36 inches, Black
Ninja SP101 Digital Air Fry Countertop Oven, 8-in-1, XL, Silver
De'Longhi La Specialista Arte Evo Espresso Machine with Grinder
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
How the Kitchn Compared the Kits
Funderburk’s review focuses on a familiar seasonal purchase: boxed gingerbread houses intended for holiday building and decorating. Rather than only comparing price or appearance, she says she assembled every contender and took notes on structural stability, candy quantity and broken pieces. The article frames the recommendations around distinct uses, including overall performance, budget, suitability for little children, taste and decorating.
The source material identifies all five category winners but supplies detailed descriptions only for Dylan’s Candy Bar and the two Favorite Day products. It names King Arthur Baking Company as the best-tasting kit and Wilton as the pick for decorators, without including the reviewer’s supporting observations or those products’ prices in the provided text.
““I got my hands on nine different kits to see which are worth your money — and time.””
— Celia Funderburk, The Kitchn editorial assistant
Details Missing for Two Picks
The supplied report excerpt does not explain why King Arthur Baking Company won the taste category or what features made Wilton the preferred kit for decorators. Their prices, contents and any drawbacks are not provided here, so readers cannot compare those picks with the detailed Favorite Day and Dylan’s Candy Bar descriptions from this material alone.
The testing reflects one reviewer’s experience with the nine kits she assembled. The source does not provide a standardized scoring table, independent taste panel or information about whether every product was tested under identical conditions. It also does not say whether the broken roof was an isolated incident or a recurring packaging issue.
Check Kit Contents Before Buying
The immediate next step for shoppers is to compare the full product listings and current prices before purchasing, particularly because the review says prices were accurate at publication and may change. Buyers considering a pre-built kit can check the box and its packaging on arrival for damaged pieces; families choosing the coloring village can weigh its easy setup against the shorter activity described in the review.
The supplied source does not announce further testing or a follow-up. It is also unclear whether The Kitchn will publish additional detail on the King Arthur and Wilton selections or update the recommendations as products and prices change.
Key Questions
Which gingerbread house kit did The Kitchn rank best overall?
The review names the Dylan’s Candy Bar kit as its best overall pick, praising its pre-built house and broad selection of candy and icing. It lists the price at $65, the highest among the nine kits tested.
Which pick is aimed at younger children?
The Kitchn names the Favorite Day pre-built holiday coloring village as its pick for little kids. It has four pre-built houses, food-safe color markers, icing and candy, and the reviewer described the activity as easy and relatively low-mess.
What was the problem with the Favorite Day pre-built house?
Funderburk said the roof on the Favorite Day pre-built gingerbread house arrived broken. The source does not say whether this was a common problem or an isolated one.
What did the report say about taste and decorating?
It names King Arthur Baking Company as the best-tasting kit and Wilton as the best for decorators. The supplied excerpt does not include the reviewer’s reasons or detailed product information for those two picks.
Source: thekitchn.com
