TL;DR
Get baking supplies delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
The Kitchn’s Ali Domrongchai compared 12 frozen breakfast sandwiches from five brands over a week, looking for a substitute for McDonald’s Egg McMuffin. She chose Jimmy Dean’s English Muffin Egg and Cheese, reporting that a four-pack cost $8 compared with $4.89 for one McDonald’s sandwich; the comparison reflects her taste test and prices at the time of publication.
The Kitchn’s Ali Domrongchai tested 12 frozen breakfast sandwiches from five brands over a week and picked Jimmy Dean’s English Muffin Egg and Cheese as her preferred substitute for a McDonald’s Egg McMuffin. The recommendation offers readers a freezer-ready option at a lower price per sandwich in the prices she reported: $2 each for Jimmy Dean, compared with $4.89 for McDonald’s.
Domrongchai said the Jimmy Dean sandwich came closest to the fast-food favorite among the products she tried. Both sandwiches have an English muffin, egg, cheddar cheese and sausage, though their ingredients and construction are not identical. The frozen sandwich uses a scrambled egg patty, while the McDonald’s version she compared it with contains a whole egg with a hard yolk. The Jimmy Dean sausage also includes chicken, according to the report.
Her review described the Jimmy Dean sandwich as less greasy without sacrificing flavor. She praised its juicy sausage, soft egg and gooey, sharp cheese. Those observations are the reviewer’s personal impressions from a taste test, not the results of a formal blind panel or a nutritional comparison; the supplied article does not report either.
The price comparison was $8 for a four-pack of Jimmy Dean sandwiches, or $2 per sandwich, against $4.89 for one Egg McMuffin. Domrongchai also listed a McDonald’s meal with a hash brown and coffee at $7.29. She noted that prices in the article were accurate when published, so shoppers may see different prices depending on location, retailer and date.
A Lower-Cost Freezer Option
The review speaks to a practical trade-off for people who regularly buy breakfast on the way to work or during early-morning travel: convenience versus cost. Based on the listed prices, keeping the frozen sandwiches at home could reduce the cost per serving and remove the need to make a separate trip to a restaurant. The comparison does not account for grocery taxes, local price differences, the cost of other meal items or the value a customer places on freshly prepared food.
It also provides a specific recommendation rather than a general claim that frozen breakfast sandwiches outperform restaurant food. Domrongchai’s conclusion is limited to her preferences and the 12 products she sampled. Readers who prioritize a whole-yolk egg, a different meat or another texture may reach a different verdict. The finding is useful as a personal product recommendation, not proof that the frozen option is universally better.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
How the Weeklong Taste Test Worked
Domrongchai framed the test around her fondness for McDonald’s Egg McMuffin and the price she encountered when buying one. She wanted a similar breakfast sandwich that could be eaten at home, then spent one week sampling a dozen sandwiches across five brands. Jimmy Dean was the eventual pick, although the source excerpt does not name every brand or provide a full ranking of all products tested.
The Kitchn’s report also refers to an earlier comparison by contributor Kate, who had chosen a Jimmy Dean Sausage Egg and Cheese Biscuit as a lower-priced counterpart to a McDonald’s biscuit sandwich. That earlier result is background to the new review, but the two tests concerned different sandwich styles. The current report focuses on an English muffin sandwich and the Egg McMuffin.
““I spent a week eating a dozen breakfast sandwiches from five different brands.””
— Ali Domrongchai, The Kitchn associate editor and reviewer
Prices and Taste Are Not Fixed
The supplied report does not give a publication date beyond saying it appeared “yesterday,” and it cautions that prices were accurate only at the time of publication. Current prices and availability are not confirmed and can vary by store and region. It is also not clear from the excerpt whether the sandwiches were prepared according to identical methods or whether the tasting was blind.
The review does not provide nutrition facts, ingredient-by-ingredient comparisons, serving weights or a complete list of the other sandwiches tested. Its description of Jimmy Dean as the closest match is therefore a reviewer’s judgment, not a claim that the two sandwiches are nutritionally equivalent or identical in taste and composition.
Check Local Prices Before Buying
The report offers no announced follow-up test or further company response. For readers weighing the recommendation, the practical next step is to compare the current per-sandwich price at a local grocery store with the price of an Egg McMuffin nearby. Checking the package for ingredients and nutrition information can also help shoppers decide whether the egg, sausage and cheese match their preferences or dietary needs.
Key Questions
Which frozen sandwich did The Kitchn recommend?
Reviewer Ali Domrongchai chose Jimmy Dean’s English Muffin Egg and Cheese as the closest match to a McDonald’s Egg McMuffin among the 12 sandwiches she tried.
How did the prices compare in the report?
The article listed a $8 four-pack of Jimmy Dean sandwiches, equivalent to $2 each, and a McDonald’s Egg McMuffin at $4.89. Prices were accurate at the time of publication and may have changed.
Are the two sandwiches made the same way?
No. The report says both include an English muffin, egg, cheddar and sausage, but the Jimmy Dean version uses a scrambled egg patty and its sausage includes chicken. The McDonald’s sandwich in the comparison has a whole egg with a hard yolk.
Was this a formal or blind taste test?
The supplied article describes a weeklong personal taste test of 12 sandwiches from five brands. It does not say whether the tasting was blind or conducted by a panel.
Does the review show that the frozen sandwich is healthier?
No. The report compares taste and listed prices, but does not provide a nutrition analysis. Readers should check the products’ nutrition facts and ingredients for a health comparison.
Source: rss
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
