The best ice cream brands in this lineup serve different cravings: I’d name Ben & Jerry’s Cherry Garcia the best overall for its recognizable cherry-and-chocolate combination, while Häagen-Dazs Vanilla Swiss Almond suits shoppers who want a more classic flavor with chocolate and almonds. For gatherings or frequent servings, Tillamook Peaches and Cream stands out for its large tub format. The main tradeoffs are flavor intensity, portion size, and whether you want a familiar pint or a bulk supply. Read on for how each option compares and which one fits your freezer and eating habits.
Get baking supplies delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Cherry Garcia is the most versatile flavor pick: its cherry and chocolate combination gives it broader appeal than the more focused Salted Caramel Core or Everything But… options.
- Package size changes the buying decision: Tillamook’s 3-gallon tub is designed for sharing or frequent use, while Häagen-Dazs cups offer portioned servings and pints suit flexible scooping.
- Häagen-Dazs offers two distinct classic-style choices: Vanilla Swiss Almond is a pint-format option, while Caramel Cone comes in individual cups for easier serving control.
- Ben & Jerry’s favors mix-ins and layered flavor: Cherry Garcia, Everything But…, and Salted Caramel Core each appeal to shoppers who want more than a plain base, but their richer combinations may not suit every palate.
- Bulk is only a value if the freezer can keep up: a large tub or multipack can be practical for groups, but smaller households may prefer formats that are easier to portion and finish while quality is at its best.
| Ben & Jerry’s Cherry Garcia Cherry Ice Cream, 16 oz |  | Best for a Distinctive Classic | Brand: Ben & Jerry’s | Flavor: Cherry Garcia | Size: 16 oz | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Häagen-Dazs Caramel Cone Ice Cream Cups, 3.6 oz, Pack of 12 |  | Best for Ready-Portioned Treats | Brand: Häagen-Dazs | Flavor: Caramel Cone | Package quantity: 12 cups | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Tillamook Peaches and Cream Ice Cream, 3-Gallon Tub |  | Best for Large Gatherings | Brand: Tillamook | Flavor: Peaches and Cream | Package size: 3 gallons | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Häagen-Dazs Vanilla Swiss Almond Ice Cream, 8 Pints |  | Best Multi-Pint Choice for Almond Fans | Brand: Häagen-Dazs | Flavor: Vanilla Swiss Almond | Quantity: 8 pints | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Ben & Jerry’s Everything But… Ice Cream Pints, Pack of 6 |  | Best for Maximum Mix-In Variety | Brand: Ben & Jerry’s | Product type: Ice cream | Package quantity: 6 pints | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Ben & Jerry’s Salted Caramel Core Ice Cream, 16 oz (Pack of 8) |  | Best for Salted Caramel Fans | Flavor: Salted Caramel Core | Ice cream base: Sweet cream | Mix-ins: Blonde brownies | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| ice cream brand | Brand | Flavor | Mix-ins |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ben & Jerry’s Cherry Garcia Ch | Ben & Jerry’s | Cherry Garcia | Cherries and fudge flakes |
| Häagen-Dazs Caramel Cone Ice C | Häagen-Dazs | Caramel Cone | — |
| Tillamook Peaches and Cream Ic | Tillamook | Peaches and Cream | — |
| Häagen-Dazs Vanilla Swiss Almo | Häagen-Dazs | Vanilla Swiss Almond | Dry-roasted almonds coated in sweet chocolate |
| Ben & Jerry’s Everything But.. | Ben & Jerry’s | — | Peanut butter cups |
| Ben & Jerry’s Salted Caramel C | — | Salted Caramel Core | Blonde brownies |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Ben & Jerry’s Cherry Garcia Cherry Ice Cream, 16 oz
Cherry Garcia earns its place for a clear, focused flavor: cherry ice cream with real cherries and fudge flakes. That pairing gives it a fruit-and-chocolate contrast rather than the many-in-the-mix approach of Ben & Jerry’s Everything But…, which combines chocolate and vanilla with several kinds of chunks. Its 16-ounce container suits a smaller household or a planned treat, but offers less flexibility for serving a crowd than the eight-pint Häagen-Dazs Vanilla Swiss Almond pack. Non-GMO ingredients, cage-free eggs, and Fairtrade-certified cocoa and sugar add sourcing credentials for buyers who value them. The tradeoff is a rich dairy dessert with substantial sugar and fat, plus common allergen concerns; its cherry-forward profile also will not suit everyone.
Pros:- Real cherries and fudge flakes create a defined fruit-and-chocolate combination.
- Non-GMO sourcing and Fairtrade-certified cocoa and sugar are stated.
- Made with cage-free eggs.
- Kosher certified.
Cons:- Contains dairy and may not suit people with relevant food allergies.
- Rich ice cream brings the sugar and fat tradeoffs associated with premium-style desserts.
- Cherry pieces and fudge flakes may not appeal to buyers who prefer smooth ice cream.
Best for: Cherry-and-chocolate fans who want a single-pint dessert with stated sourcing and dietary certifications.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking a low-sugar or dairy-free treat, or those who prefer a simple vanilla flavor without fruit or fudge pieces.
- Brand:Ben & Jerry’s
- Flavor:Cherry Garcia
- Size:16 oz
- Mix-ins:Cherries and fudge flakes
- Ingredient sourcing:Non-GMO sourced ingredients
- Eggs:Cage-free
- Certifications:Kosher; Fairtrade-certified cocoa and sugar
Our verdict“Choose Cherry Garcia for a compact cherry-and-fudge treat with sourcing credentials, but skip it if you want a lighter or smoother option.”
Häagen-Dazs Caramel Cone Ice Cream Cups, 3.6 oz, Pack of 12
Caramel Cone cups stand apart from the pint formats here by packaging the dessert as twelve individual 3.6-ounce servings. That makes portions easy to hand out or store separately, unlike Tillamook Peaches and Cream, whose three-gallon foodservice tub is built for large-scale serving and needs ample freezer room. The cups also offer more portion control than opening a full container, though the supplied details do not specify the caramel-cone ingredients or texture, so buyers should check the package if mix-ins or allergens matter to them. Compared with Cherry Garcia, this listing gives a household multiple ready-to-serve portions rather than one 16-ounce tub. The tradeoff is less flexibility over serving size and more individual packaging than a single larger container.
Pros:- Twelve cups provide separate servings for sharing or storing.
- Each cup has a specified 3.6-ounce serving size.
- Individual packaging avoids scooping from a shared container.
Cons:- Fixed-size cups offer less control over portion size than a tub or pint.
- The listing does not provide detailed ingredient or certification information.
- Individual cups create more packaging than one large container.
Best for: Households, hosts, or workplace freezers that want individually portioned servings without scooping from a shared tub.
Not ideal for: Buyers who prefer to choose their own serving size, want a single large container, or need ingredient details not provided in this listing.
- Brand:Häagen-Dazs
- Flavor:Caramel Cone
- Package quantity:12 cups
- Serving size:3.6 oz per cup
- Product format:Individual ice cream cups
- Total listed servings:12 individually portioned cups
Our verdict“Pick these cups for convenient, portioned servings, but choose a tub if serving size flexibility matters more.”
Tillamook Peaches and Cream Ice Cream, 3-Gallon Tub
Tillamook Peaches and Cream is the volume choice in this group: a three-gallon foodservice tub suited to repeated serving, rather than a household pint or individually packed dessert. That capacity makes it a more practical fit for a large gathering or foodservice setting than Häagen-Dazs Caramel Cone cups, which arrive in twelve fixed 3.6-ounce portions. Its peach-and-cream flavor also offers a fruit-led alternative to the chocolate-heavy mix-ins in Ben & Jerry’s Everything But…. The supplied details describe it as rich and creamy but do not specify ingredients, certifications, or serving count, so buyers with dietary requirements should verify the tub label. The major drawback is straightforward: three gallons take substantial freezer space, and the format may be excessive for a small household.
Pros:- Three-gallon capacity suits serving many portions.
- Peaches and cream provides a fruit-forward alternative to chocolate-heavy flavors.
- Foodservice tub format is suited to repeated serving.
Cons:- Requires substantial freezer space.
- Large volume may be impractical for occasional or small-household use.
- The provided product details do not state certifications or a full ingredient list.
Best for: Event organizers, foodservice buyers, and large households that need a substantial tub for repeated servings.
Not ideal for: Small households or anyone with limited freezer capacity, since the three-gallon format is far larger than the pint and cup options.
- Brand:Tillamook
- Flavor:Peaches and Cream
- Package size:3 gallons
- Product format:Foodservice tub
- Product type:Ice cream
- Description:Rich, creamy ice cream
Our verdict“Choose this tub for group serving and ample freezer space; smaller households are better served by pint or cup formats.”
Häagen-Dazs Vanilla Swiss Almond Ice Cream, 8 Pints
Vanilla Swiss Almond takes familiar vanilla in a more textured direction, pairing it with dry-roasted almonds coated in sweet chocolate. The eight-pint quantity makes it more useful for stocking a freezer or serving on multiple occasions than Ben & Jerry’s Cherry Garcia, which comes as one 16-ounce container. Its flavor is also more focused than Ben & Jerry’s Everything But…, whose chocolate and vanilla bases carry several different mix-ins. Gluten-free and kosher dairy labeling adds useful information for some shoppers, but this is not an allergy-friendly choice for people avoiding almonds, dairy, or chocolate ingredients. The multipack requires freezer room, and buyers seeking plain vanilla may find the almonds and chocolate coating get in the way of a simple, versatile scoop.
Pros:- Dry-roasted almonds coated in sweet chocolate add crunch to the vanilla base.
- Eight pints provide multiple separate containers.
- Labeled gluten-free.
- Kosher dairy certified.
Cons:- Contains almonds and dairy, limiting suitability for people avoiding those ingredients.
- Eight pints require substantial freezer space.
- The chocolate-coated almonds make it less versatile than plain vanilla.
Best for: Vanilla-and-almond fans who want several pints on hand and can use a product labeled gluten-free and kosher dairy.
Not ideal for: People avoiding almonds or dairy, or buyers who want plain vanilla without chocolate-coated nut pieces.
- Brand:Häagen-Dazs
- Flavor:Vanilla Swiss Almond
- Quantity:8 pints
- Base:Vanilla ice cream
- Mix-ins:Dry-roasted almonds coated in sweet chocolate
- Dietary information:Gluten-free
- Certification:Kosher dairy
Our verdict“Choose this multipack if you want vanilla with chocolate-coated almond crunch; skip it if you need plain or nut-free ice cream.”
Ben & Jerry’s Everything But… Ice Cream Pints, Pack of 6
Everything But… is the most mix-in-heavy choice in this lineup, combining chocolate and vanilla ice creams with peanut butter cups, fudge-covered toffee, white chocolatey chunks, and fudge-covered almonds. That variety makes it a stronger fit for shoppers who want several textures in one scoop than Cherry Garcia, whose cherry-and-fudge combination stays more focused. The six-pint pack also gives more individual containers than Cherry Garcia’s single 16-ounce tub, but it takes more freezer room and commits buyers to the same flavor across multiple pints. The nut ingredients are a serious limitation for anyone managing peanut or almond allergies, and dairy is also present. Compared with the simpler Häagen-Dazs Vanilla Swiss Almond, this option offers more kinds of mix-ins, but its combination of flavors and textures is less restrained.
Pros:- Combines chocolate and vanilla ice creams in one product.
- Includes peanut butter cups, fudge-covered toffee, white chocolatey chunks, and fudge-covered almonds.
- Six pints provide separate containers for sharing or storing.
Cons:- Contains peanuts, almonds, and dairy, creating significant allergen limitations.
- Multiple rich mix-ins may be too busy for buyers who prefer a simpler flavor.
- Six pints require more freezer space than a single tub.
Best for: Adventurous dessert fans who want chocolate and vanilla together with several crunchy, chocolatey mix-ins across multiple pints.
Not ideal for: People avoiding peanuts, almonds, or dairy, and buyers who prefer one simple flavor or have limited freezer space.
- Brand:Ben & Jerry’s
- Product type:Ice cream
- Package quantity:6 pints
- Ice cream flavors:Chocolate and vanilla
- Mix-ins:Peanut butter cups
- Additional mix-ins:Fudge-covered toffee pieces, white chocolatey chunks, and fudge-covered almonds
- Stated allergens:Peanuts, almonds, and dairy
Our verdict“Choose this pack for varied, chocolate-forward mix-ins across several pints, but avoid it if nut allergens or simpler flavors are a concern.”
Ben & Jerry’s Salted Caramel Core Ice Cream, 16 oz (Pack of 8)
I’d pick this Ben & Jerry’s flavor for shoppers who want distinct layers of sweetness and texture rather than a straightforward scoop. The sweet cream base is paired with blonde brownie pieces and a concentrated salted caramel core, giving it more of a dessert-within-a-dessert feel than the fruit-forward Cherry Garcia. Compared with Ben & Jerry’s Everything But…, this pint has a more focused flavor profile; that makes the caramel the main event, but offers less variety in each bite. Its non-GMO ingredients, cage-free eggs, and Fairtrade-certified components may also matter to buyers who weigh sourcing alongside flavor. The tradeoff is a rich, sweet style, and a pack of eight can be a lot for a small household. I’d skip it if you prefer lighter flavors or only want one pint.
Pros:- Salted caramel core adds a concentrated caramel contrast to the sweet cream base
- Blonde brownie pieces provide a chewy texture alongside the smooth ice cream
- Non-GMO sourced ingredients, cage-free eggs, and Fairtrade-certified components
- Eight-pint pack suits sharing or keeping multiple servings on hand
Cons:- Rich, sweet flavor may not suit shoppers looking for a lighter dessert
- Eight pints may be excessive for households with limited freezer space or low consumption
- The focused caramel profile offers less flavor variety than Ben & Jerry’s Everything But…
Best for: Salted caramel dessert fans and households that will share or steadily work through eight pints
Not ideal for: Single-person households seeking just one pint, or shoppers who prefer fruit-forward, less-rich ice cream
- Flavor:Salted Caramel Core
- Ice cream base:Sweet cream
- Mix-ins:Blonde brownies
- Core:Salted caramel
- Container size:16 oz
- Pack quantity:8
- Ingredient attributes:Non-GMO sourced ingredients, cage-free eggs, and Fairtrade Certified ingredients
Our verdict“Choose this eight-pint pack if salted caramel and brownie pieces are your priority and you have enough people or freezer space to make use of it.”
How We Picked
I compared the six listed options on the factors that shape a practical ice cream purchase: flavor character, format, serving flexibility, and likely use. I also looked at how each option distinguishes itself within the lineup, from mix-in-heavy pints to individual cups and a large tub. Because package sizes vary widely, I treated convenience and storage as part of the product experience rather than assuming a larger pack is automatically a better buy.
The ranking favors options with a clear use case and wider appeal, while still giving credit to specialized choices. Cherry Garcia leads as a recognizable, balanced flavor; the Häagen-Dazs picks follow for classic combinations and portion convenience. More specific or larger-format choices rank lower for general use, not because they lack appeal, but because they suit narrower cravings, bigger households, or planned occasions better.
| ice cream brand | Brand | Flavor | Mix-ins |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ben & Jerry’s Cherry Garcia Ch | Ben & Jerry’s | Cherry Garcia | Cherries and fudge flakes |
| Häagen-Dazs Caramel Cone Ice C | Häagen-Dazs | Caramel Cone | — |
| Tillamook Peaches and Cream Ic | Tillamook | Peaches and Cream | — |
| Häagen-Dazs Vanilla Swiss Almo | Häagen-Dazs | Vanilla Swiss Almond | Dry-roasted almonds coated in sweet chocolate |
| Ben & Jerry’s Everything But.. | Ben & Jerry’s | — | Peanut butter cups |
| Ben & Jerry’s Salted Caramel C | — | Salted Caramel Core | Blonde brownies |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Ice Cream Brands
Choosing among these brands is less about a universal winner and more about matching flavor, format, and freezer habits. I’d decide how the ice cream will be served before choosing a package, especially when comparing single cups, pints, multipacks, and a large tub.
Choose the Format Before the Flavor
A pint is flexible: it works for scooping into bowls, sharing casually, or keeping one flavor on hand without committing to a large container. Single-serve cups make portions simpler and can reduce the need to scoop, but they create more individual packaging. Large tubs make sense when serving a crowd or using ice cream repeatedly, yet they need substantial freezer space and a plan for keeping the container accessible. A common mistake is buying a bulk format because it seems convenient, then finding that it crowds the freezer or outlasts the occasion. Match the package to how many people will eat it and how often you expect to serve it.
Match Flavor Complexity to Your Crowd
Mix-ins and layered centers make a flavor feel more like a composed dessert, but they can divide a group more than a familiar, simpler combination. Cherry Garcia and Vanilla Swiss Almond pair recognizable bases with add-ins, while Salted Caramel Core and Everything But… lean into more concentrated, varied flavor experiences. For a mixed group, choose a flavor whose main note is easy to recognize rather than assuming everyone wants the most elaborate option. If you are stocking only one container, consider whether its flavor works both on its own and alongside pie, cake, or other desserts. A more distinctive flavor can be a better treat for an individual than a dependable crowd choice.
Think About Portion Control and Serving Effort
Individual cups provide a built-in portion, which can help when serving guests or packing a snack. Pints give more control over serving size but require a scoop and may be harder to portion neatly when very firm. A large tub can serve many people efficiently, though scooping from a deep container may take more effort and can lead to uneven servings. Do not judge convenience by package size alone: the easiest container depends on who will serve it and where. If you want a grab-and-serve option, cups may be more practical; if you want adaptable portions, a pint is usually easier to manage.
Check Freezer Space and Pack Count
Multipacks can be useful for households that already know they enjoy a flavor, but they take up more space and reduce variety within the purchase. A single pint leaves room to change flavors on the next shop, while a pack of cups can be easier to distribute among several people. The large Tillamook tub calls for a different kind of planning: measure available freezer space and think about how quickly it will be served. Buyers often focus on the number of containers without checking the total volume or the shape of the packaging. A container that fits your shelf is more useful than a larger supply that is difficult to store.
Pay More Attention to Use Than Brand Name
Brand preference can narrow the choices, but the best fit still depends on the occasion. A pint with pronounced mix-ins may suit a small personal treat, while portioned cups can simplify a gathering and a large tub can support repeated group servings. Paying for a format that saves serving effort may make sense when hosting; it is less helpful if you mainly want one bowl at a time. Likewise, choosing a familiar brand does not guarantee that a particular flavor will suit everyone. Start with the job the ice cream needs to do, then choose the brand and flavor that meet it.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which of these ice creams is the safest choice for serving a mixed group?
I’d start with Cherry Garcia if you want a recognizable flavor with both fruit and chocolate, or choose Caramel Cone cups when individual portions make serving easier. A group with varied preferences may respond better to familiar flavor notes than to a heavily layered or highly specific combination. If you are hosting, check whether guests have ingredient restrictions before choosing, since the listed flavor names alone do not provide enough information about allergens. For a larger gathering, format may matter as much as flavor: cups reduce scooping and make portions straightforward.
Should I choose a multipack or buy a single pint?
A multipack is a better fit when you already know the flavor suits your household and you have freezer space for several containers. A single pint gives you more freedom to change flavors and is a lower-commitment way to try a specific option. Think about how often the ice cream will be eaten, not just how many servings the package appears to contain. If your freezer is shared or small, several containers can be awkward to store even when the format is convenient. For a first purchase, a smaller format is often the more flexible choice.
Is a large tub a good choice for a household that eats ice cream occasionally?
Usually, a large tub makes more sense for frequent servings, gatherings, or a household that can share it regularly. Occasional eaters may find a pint or portioned cups easier to store and use without dedicating a large area of the freezer. Before choosing a bulk container, consider both its footprint and whether you can serve it conveniently. A large format can be practical when planned for a party, but less so when it sits in a crowded freezer between occasional treats. Choose based on likely use rather than the assumption that more volume is always more convenient.
Which option should I pick if I prefer classic flavors over lots of mix-ins?
Within this lineup, Häagen-Dazs Vanilla Swiss Almond is the closest fit for a classic-style choice, though it still includes chocolate and almonds rather than being plain vanilla. The other Ben & Jerry’s options lean into more prominent combinations, centers, or multiple mix-ins. If you want the simplest possible flavor, none of these six is a plain vanilla option, so check the current product label or consider a different flavor from the brand. This distinction matters if you want ice cream to pair with another dessert without competing with it.
How do I choose between Caramel Cone and Salted Caramel Core?
Choose Caramel Cone cups if individual servings and a familiar caramel-and-cone-inspired profile appeal to you. Salted Caramel Core is the more focused choice for someone specifically craving salted caramel and a pronounced center. The cup format favors portion convenience, while the pint-style pack gives you a different way to serve and share the flavor. If you are unsure how much caramel intensity you want, the more familiar cone-inspired option may feel like the safer starting point. Check the package details before buying, since these options differ in both flavor and pack format.
Conclusion
Best overall: I’d choose Ben & Jerry’s Cherry Garcia for its familiar cherry-and-chocolate pairing and broad appeal. Best value for group serving: Tillamook Peaches and Cream makes the most sense when a household can use a large tub and has freezer room. Best premium-style classic: Häagen-Dazs Vanilla Swiss Almond suits shoppers who want a familiar base with chocolate and almonds. Best for beginners: Häagen-Dazs Caramel Cone cups offer an approachable flavor and easy portions. Best for mix-in fans: Ben & Jerry’s Everything But… delivers a busier combination, while Salted Caramel Core is the pick for a specific caramel craving. If you are choosing just one, start with Cherry Garcia; choose by format first when serving convenience or freezer space is the bigger concern.
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
